22 Nov 2006

Mixing welfare and elitism in Singapore

By Alex Au

SINGAPORE - Is Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong moving to soften the island state's time-tested capitalist credentials with state welfare policies for the poor?

Growing economic inequality has put Lee to the political test, one that is challenging his economic lieutenants to devise ways to redistribute national wealth consistent with Singapore's strong laissez-faire capitalist tradition. The formula they've arrived at, however, seems likely to widen rather than bridge the divide.

In mid-November, Lee announced government plans to raise the goods and service tax (GST) from 5% to 7%. The tax hike is designed to generate about S$1.5 billion (US$960 million) annually, funds that will be earmarked to develop a more generous social safety net. "It's essential for us to tilt the balance [of spending] in favor of lower-income Singaporeans because globalization is going to strain our social compact," Lee said upon announcing the policy.

It was an unusually candid admission for the leader of the ruling People's Action Party (PAP), the political machine that Lee's father, former premier and current Mentor Minister Lee Kuan Yew, founded and that has ruled Singapore uninterrupted since the country's founding in 1959. Strict adherence to neo-liberal economic prescriptions and policy promotion of an export-oriented economy contributed to Singapore's emergence as one of Asia's richest countries in the 1980s and 1990s.

Now, it appears those same policies are disproportionately lifting the top tier of society while leaving a growing number of lower-wage earners in the economic lurch. That trend arguably began with the 1997-98 Asian financial crisis when, government statistics show, the wages of lower-skilled workers fell by about one-third.

Despite economic recovery, the income gap has continued to widen as Singapore's past advantage in manufacturing industries has been eroded by China and other lower-cost countries in the region. Over the past five years, about 20% of Singapore's households have suffered from declining incomes. And that's arguably starting to take a toll on the PAP's popularity.

Political reaction

Prime Minister Lee's pronouncements and policies are clearly a reaction to those shifting perceptions. Details of the various proposed new welfare schemes - known provisionally as "offset packages" - will be announced in February along with the state budget. Indications are that existing modest schemes to subsidize elderly health care, housing and education will be topped up and many new welfare schemes introduced.

Lee has said that the so-called "workfare bonus" - an unprecedented cash payout to low-wage earners introduced as a one-off measure just weeks before last May's general election - would be employed to redistribute government budget surpluses back to taxpayers.

The PAP in the run-up to the polls doled out S$150 million of bonuses to about 330,000 low-wage earners, representing about 9% of Singapore's population of citizens and permanent residents. That payout anticipated but didn't blunt opposition parties' class-oriented attacks against the PAP-dominated government, claiming it systematically neglected the island state's many low-wage earners.

The PAP won those polls handily, capturing 82 of 84 parliamentary seats - though the weak opposition has since the 1980s claimed that the election system is structured and regulated in ways that inhibit small parties from fielding candidates, including the requirement that parties must assemble an ethnically balanced six-member committee to contest some electoral constituencies.

Yet the prickly income-inequality issue was quickly resurrected one month after the elections when a blogger writing under the pseudonym Mr Brown pointedly asked why official data that showed that 20% of national households were suffering from declining incomes were released after rather than before the general polls.

For his pains, Mr Brown's regular column in the government-owned Today newspaper was brusquely terminated - fueling outrage in Internet chat rooms about the government's heavy-handedness and apparent lack of transparency. Meanwhile, the PAP-led government proposed this month to tighten laws that govern the Internet as part of an overhaul of the national penal code.

The proposed amendments would hold Internet users liable for statements the government deemed to "cause public mischief" or "wound racial feelings". If passed, the legislation would appear to institutionalize the ban on posting inflammatory political content the government enforced temporarily in the run-up to this year's polls and would give it broad new powers to curtail freedom of expression.

It's unclear whether public debates over the Internet about the GST rise would be considered "mischievous" under the proposed new rules. Some commentators have already dared to note that raising the consumption tax is by definition regressive and will hit poor households harder than rich ones as they are forced to spend a greater proportion of their income on tax-inflated necessities.

The Singapore Chinese Chamber of Commerce, a grouping of about 4,000 mostly small businesses, likewise took the chance to express its "great concern and disappointment" about the tax hike. That's because the policy has the dual purpose of also covering the expected shortfall in tax revenues that will occur when the government cuts corporate-tax rates from their current level of 20%. It has not yet been announced when the new lower tax rate will take effect, but Singapore is under growing competitive pressure to reduce its tax rates to remain attractive to foreign investors.

To justify his government's corporate-tax cut, Lee recently said in parliament that developing Baltic nations such as Latvia and Lithuania levy a flat 15% tax on corporations. More to the competitive point, Hong Kong's top personal income-tax rate is currently 16%, a full 4 percentage points lower than Singapore's rate.

"Such a reduction would only benefit profitable companies and not the significant majority of small and medium-sized enterprises which have to contend with high business overheads and a dwindling bottom line," the Singapore Chinese Chamber of Commerce said in a statement.

The unspoken subtext is that raising the GST while cutting corporate taxes will in effect shift the tax burden from big companies to ordinary citizens, particularly lower-income Singaporeans, some commentators say.

While the details of the promised new welfare schemes are still pending, the PAP-led government is headed into an uncharted and difficult interventionist direction.

On the surface, Lee's government appears to have shaken its historical aversion to welfare schemes and taken on board providing long-term state assistance to a large cross section of the population. Singapore currently does not impose minimum wages, nor are there state-backed pension plans as in many Western countries. In nanny-state fashion, each Singaporean is currently compelled by law to set aside a certain proportion of his or her income for retirement purposes.

The government insists it will fashion the new assistance schemes in a way that avoids institutionalizing the economic lethargy and dependence inherent in Western welfare systems. Lee recently told parliament: "I would like to caution members that we should proceed with care ... it is a real slippery slope. And many, many social-welfare schemes which have ended up in serious trouble have started off with good intentions."

Notwithstanding those words, the scale of the proposed changes suggests a fundamental philosophical shift for the PAP. That's largely because the growing chorus of complaints about the widening income gap has grown politically too loud to ignore.

Entrenched elitism

The issue is also significantly tied to growing public perceptions about elitism among PAP members of parliament (MPs) and their family members - a perceived social arrogance and economic selfishness that increasingly sticks in the craw of many Singaporeans, particularly among low-wage earners.

Sin Boon Ann, a PAP MP, recently highlighted the danger of class conflict in a speech to parliament. "The perception exists that Singapore is a society bifurcated between the elites and the commoners, the scholars and the normal streams, the gifted and the ordinary, the [public housing] dwellers and the private property owner, the rich and the poor," the parliamentarian said. It is necessary to "break down the institution of snobbery within our society", he said.

He spoke amid a surge in cyber-criticism aimed at PAP MP Wee Siew Kim. In a now-famous exchange in Singapore's vibrant blogosphere, Derek Wee (no relation to the parliamentarian) wrote in his blog on October 12 about his economic insecurities as he approached middle age. He opined that Singapore's liberal immigration policies were putting his job at risk, and he urged the government to be more understanding of ordinary citizens' plight.

An 18-year-old girl in her own blog replied and disparaged Derek Wee's concerns, saying, "If you're not good enough, life will kick you in the balls ... There's no point in lambasting the government for making our society one that is, I quote, 'far too survival-of-fittest'.

"If uncertainty of success offends you so much, you will certainly be poor and miserable," the young blogger added. She went on to refer to Derek Wee as "one of many wretched, under-motivated, over-assuming leeches in our country", and rounded off her attack by telling him to "get out of my elite uncaring face".

It was quickly discovered that the girl, Wee Shu Min, was the daughter of a less-known PAP MP, demonstrating to many Internet users that Singapore's highly touted meritocracy was being undermined by an intolerant elitism at the top. Her name, "Wee Shu Min", rocketed to the top of keyword searches in Singapore as measured by Technorati.com.

Her father, Wee Siew Kim, later unapologetically waded into the controversy. "I think if you cut through the insensitivity of the language, her basic point is reasonable," he told the government-controlled Straits Times newspaper, adding: "Some people cannot take the brutal truth and that sort of language, so she ought to learn from it."

It is against this ferment that Lee's government is now emphasizing the need for long-term social support for the poor, and at the same time moving to curtail political debate over the Internet. Yet Lee's tax reforms and welfare promises are unlikely to bridge quickly the divide between his government and its low-income constituents. It's an issue that promises to dominate Singapore's popular discourse and give Lee political headaches for years to come.

Alex Au is an independent social and political commentator and freelance writer based in Singapore. He often speaks at public forums on politics, culture and gay issues.


10 comments:

Anonymous said...

derekwee.blogspot.com

jobscopevsreliance.blogspot.com

sipeiboeysong.blogspot.com

good to read

Anonymous said...

elitism and welfare are not contradictory; the better off should help the less well off, and elite members should feel they owe something to society (not the reverse - only an uncultured elite would think that way)

antipathy said...

i think Alex Au, should be careful of the usage of the word pseudonym, coz it conveys a sense that it is something hidden. mrbrown's real name is very well known, his face is recognizable and all that. I think a more proper term would be nom de guerre? One of the contentious issues that K bhavani raised was that mrbrown was hiding behind a pseudonym. That is a totally unfair characterization.

Anonymous said...

bhavani was just piling on the crime sheet, so that the real reason for not liking mr brown looks less obvious

Anonymous said...

The fact remains that Wee Siew Kim has received much flak and bricks from the offended masses. Yet surprisingly, little reprise nor public reprimand has been forthcoming from his GRC and party. And we have yet to read about him stepping down whereas his statements would have drawn immediate political suicide even in the Baltic states

Isn't this enough testimony of the 'elites' confidence of their power to disregard public opinion? Isn't his daughter's declaration 'endorsed' in so ways in annoucing to Singaporeans that they better be aware of class differences and respect the divisions?

Anonymous said...

the leaders dont make mistakes; since they selected him, he is good; who cares about the chattering classes?

Matilah_Singapura said...

You can't solve "social problems" by robbing the productivity by taxation (in this case the ability to consume) and re-distributing it to the "needy".

A welfare state, regardless of how it is funded is the begining of the end. Those who receive the welfare are in essenced "trapped" and thus will vote accordingly... invariably for more welfare for themselves.

It is bad enough that HDB upgrade policies are unashamedly umbillically tied to "motivating"citizens - especially the heartlanders - to cast their votes for the party promising goodies. The one party system ensures that these folks will take away goodies if they do not get a "vote of confidence".

All taxes are BAD taxes — some worse than others. Consumption taxes hit the poor disproportionately — the argument of "wealth distribution" is a nonsense. What happens is that state power increases, because state power is funded by taxes.

Matilah Singapura!

Anonymous said...

Me thinks the current increase in GST is another long term strategy of PAP to siphon money from the public and use it to hold the public to ransom in the next election. They will use it especailly against those wards that they suspect will vote in the opposition. For example: PAP will threaten that if the wards voted for the opposition than it is tantamount to a lack of confidence in them (PAP) and will exclude the poor families of these ward from the 2% gst revenues collected.

The Human Battery said...

I really don't know why you people complain so much! Look at me! I am a happy Human Battery living blissfully on my Matrix Island, governed by my all-knowing Matrix Master (MM).

Come take the blue pill. You will be happy too :)

Anonymous said...

bingo
bingo online
online bingo
bingo casino
play bingo
internet bingo
play bingo online
play online bingo
bingo casinos
bingo sites
bingo web sites
bingo websites
top bingo casinos
best bingo casinos
online bingo casinos
bingo casinos online
internet bingo casinos
bingo
bingo online
online bingo
bingo casino
play bingo
internet bingo
play bingo online
play online bingo
bingo casinos
bingo sites
bingo web sites
bingo websites
top bingo casinos
best bingo casinos
online bingo casinos
bingo casinos online
internet bingo casinos
hoodia
hoodia diet pills
hoodia gordonii
pure hoodia
hoodia side effects
hoodia patch
hoodia prices
buy hoodia
compare hoodia
best hoodia
hoodia pills
hoodia pill
hoodia diet pill
hoodia diet
hoodia
hoodia diet pills
hoodia gordonii
pure hoodia
hoodia side effects
hoodia patch
hoodia prices
buy hoodia
compare hoodia
best hoodia
hoodia pills
hoodia pill
hoodia diet pill
hoodia diet
Bingo Web Sites
Bingo Web Sites Contact Us 
Bingo Web Sites Sitemap
Bingo Web Sites Articles
Bingo Web Sites Support
Top Bingo Casinos Linkdomain
Bingo Websites
Saints And Sinner Bingo Contact Us
Saints And Sinner Bingo Sitemap
Bingo Articles 1
Online Internet Best Top Bingo Casinos Articles 1
Saints And Sinner Bingo Faq
Saints And Sinner Bingo Support
Bingo Websites Index 1
Bingo Web Sites Index 1
Casino Games Info
Baccarat
Backgammon
Blackjack
Craps
Keno
Poker
Roulette
Slots
Sportsbook
Video Poker
Best Bingo Casinos Linkdomain
Hoodia Prices
Contact
Site Map
Articles
Support
Hoodia Prices Index 1
Hoodia Side Effects Index 1
Hoodia Patch Index 1
Compare Hoodia Linkdomain
Hoodia Prices
Articles
Contact
Sitemap
Support
Hoodia Prices Index 1
Hoodia Side Effects Index 1
Hoodia Patch Index 1
Best Hoodia Linkdomain
Bingo Articles
bingo dauber bingo daubers bingo delta bingo delta hill richmond bingo deposit free no online bingo deposit no bingo embroidery designs bingo employment joyland bingo entertainment bingo equipment bingo erie fort golden nugget bingo eyed three bingo fabric material bingo flashboard bingo for baby shower bingo for cash bingo for children to play online for free bingo for free bingo for kids bingo for prizes bingo for sale bingo fortune bingo free bingo free bonus bingo free download bingo free free play bingo free game bingo free game online bingo free give money play site that bingo free money online win bingo free money real win bingo free online bingo free online play bingo free play bingo free to play and win cash bingo free tournaments bingo from hall mall shopping underbelly wrestling bingo fuel bingo fuel reactor bingo fun bingo fundraiser bingo funland bingo gala bingo gambling bingo game bingo game board bingo game boards bingo game card bingo game cards bingo game download bingo game downloads bingo game ellison bingo game for kids bingo game free money bingo game internet bingo game kid online bingo game locations in fairfield ct. bingo game maker bingo game online bingo game online play bingo game rule bingo game rules bingo game set bingo game software bingo game supplies bingo game template bingo game+directory bingo games bingo games at niagara falls canada bingo games for free bingo games for kids bingo games for mental health clubhouses bingo games for travel bingo games free for prizes bingo games in italian language bingo games in redding calif bingo games in san diego bingo games niagara falls canada bingo games online bingo games terre haute indiana bingo games to play bingo games to play for free bingo games vegas style bingo gifts bingo golden hall nugget bingo golden nugget bingo graphics bingo grid bingo gubelmann bingo guide online bingo hall bingo hall locations bingo hall near hwy 290 telge rd in houston bingo hall newspaper bingo halls bingo halls california bingo halls in california bingo halls in northern virginia bingo halls in pa bingo halls in williamsport pa bingo halls oh bingo halls richmond hill ontario bingo hard cards bingo hey bingo highest payout bingo highway bingo history bingo hotspot bingo in brewster bingo in charles town wv bingo in colorado bingo in gwinnett county bingo in italy bingo in john's pass florida bingo in kauai hawaii bingo in largo florida bingo in las vegas bingo in littleton bingo in massapequa bingo in tallahassee florida bingo info bingo information bingo internet bingo items bingo jacksonville florida bingo jacksonville ga bingo jokes bingo kenoly bingo king bingo king power bingo bingo knight bingo las vegas bingo las vegas nv bingo lesson plan bingo locations in monmouth county nj bingo long 30 year anniversary bingo long book review bingo long novel bingo long ucla bingo lotto bingo lures bingo lyrics bingo machine bingo machine sales and service bingo machines bingo machines to buy bingo macros bingo maker bingo management software bingo mania bingo manufacture bingo marker bingo daubers bingo markers bingo master boards bingo math multiplication facts bingo math questions bingo mecca bingo mega draw national lottery winner bingo merriex profile basketball bingo mp3 bingo mugs bingo near phoenix az bingo network gaming bingo news bingo night at the firehall bingo nova bingo novelties bingo number generator bingo number in plain dealer bingo numbers bingo online games bingo online no deposit free cash bingo online play bingo online s bingo online slot bingo packages available at oneida casino bingo palace bingo paper bingo paper case 4 faces bingo paper quick dab bingo party bingo party games bingo party supplies bingo pattern bingo patterns bingo pictures bingo pinball bingo pinball machines bingo places in humble texas bingo play bingo playing cards bingo playland bingo plays bingo pogo.ez win bingo polvorines bingo pool bingo posters bingo powerpoints bingo princesa bingo print cloth material bingo prizes bingo products bingo promotion bingo promotions bingo pull tabs bingo reading bingo reno bingo romer bingo room bingo rule bingo rules bingo rules and regulations bingo saint sinner bingo sales software bingo screensaver bingo set bingo set professional bingo sets bingo sheet bingo sheets bingo shirt bingo short animated film bingo shutter card bingo shutter cards bingo sign up bonus bingo site bingo sites south australia bingo slide card bingo slot bingo slot machine bingo slot machine online bingo slot machine online casino bingo slot machines bingo slots bingo software bingo song bingo sound bingo statistics bingo store bingo stores bingo stuff bingo sun bingo sunshine bingo suplies bingo supplier bingo suppliers bingo supplies bingo supplies canada bingo supplies daubers bingo supplies florida bingo supplies in bingo supplies maryland bingo supplies nj bingo supplies san diego bingo supplies toronto bingo supplies wholesale bingo supply bingo supply store bingo supply stores bingo template bingo templates bingo terms bingo the bear bingo the clown disregard this play bingo theme party bingo tickets bingo tournament bingo tractors bingo tv bingo uk bingo variations bingo virgin bingo was his name bingo waterford wisconsin bingo wav bingo wavripperconverter bingo websites where you accumulate points to get prizes bingo wholesale bingo wings bingo winners bingo worksheet bingo yahoo bingo zone black listed bingo sites blackout bingo blank baby shower bingo card blank bingo blank bingo balls blank bingo board blank bingo board patterns blank bingo card blank bingo cards blank bingo cards science blank bingo cards to print blank bingo game blank bingo grid blank bingo grid for students blank bingo matrix blank bridal shower bingo sheets book bingo boss bingo inc. bratwurst bingo bridal bingo bridal bingo blank bridal bingo cards bridal bingo game bridal bingo printout bridal gift bingo bridal shower bingo bridal shower bingo cards bridal shower bingo game bridal shower bingo games bridal shower games bingo bridal shower gift bingo bride bingo bride bingo cards bull shit bingo bullet bingo buzzword bingo calgary bingo halls calgary bingo jackpot junction special events camp bingo calling canada bingo game canadian bingo canadian bingo equipment suppliers canadian bingo online canadian jackpot bingo car bingo career bingo casino bingo blackjack chance and probability games like bingo chance and probability like bingo charitable bingo manager cheerios bingo game cherokee bingo child bingo cards childrens bingo game chinese manufacturers bingo balls chit chat bingo choctaw bingo choctaw bingo chords choctaw bingo lyrics choctaw bingo lyrics chords chopper bingo christmas bingo christmas bingo card christmas bingo cards to print christmas bingo game church bingo maryland cincinnati ohio bingo clip art for bingo cards clock bingo colors bingo paper commercial talking bingo games computerized bingo card ordinance coopers bingo amusements coopers prize bingo cow patty bingo cow pie bingo cowpie bingo create a bingo game create bingo cards create bingo game create free bingo cards for baby shower create your own bingo card creating bingo cards creating number for bingo from scratch ct bingo fraud law custom bingo cards customize bingo cards cyber bingo dayton ohio bingo dejope bingo dejope bingo and entertainment delta bingo delta bingo richmond hill design and print baby bingo sheets design bingo poster free digital bingo machine district of columbia delta bingo richmond hill dora + printable + bingo cards dora bingo dora bingo game download free bingo downloadable baby bingo easy online real bingo ebay store bingo store educational games vocabulary bingo electronic bingo boards electronic bingo games electronic bingo machines elementary bingo game ellison king of the bingo game empty refillable bingo dauber expert software bingo ez win bingo fall bingo game family bingo fast bingo federal laws on instant bingo first day activities bingo fisher price farm bingo flash bingo