10 Aug 2006

Singapore Likes to Remake Itself Often



I remember a number of political maxims. One is that for any government "Good things should be done a little at a time; bad things should be done all at once", so that the pain passes and people keep hearing the good news. The other is that "When you are making big changes, always reassure people these are just minor adjustments, with all kinds of familiar features and precedents, so that the people do not get frightened and confused; when nothing much is happening, keep telling people all those exciting things you are doing to make their life more interesting." To me those rules are not Machiavellian, just simple practical sense.

If you read Straits Times regularly, you would keep hearing that Singapore is remaking itself. In fact, a few years ago there was actually a Remake Singapore Committee working out a programme for Singapore to remake itself. More or less at the same time, bartop dancing was hotly discussed, and eventually legalized; a briefer discussion about the pros and cons of allowing bungee jumping was carried out, ending with the installation of the Clark Quay bungee machine (which was recently in the news again because of a cable coming loose). There was some kind of announcement that homosexuals can now be appointed to senior positions in the public sector - they were previously considered to have higher security risks due to the possibility of closet blackmail. This encouraged the gay community into seeking permits to bring in various activities, but after a few rejections things quietened down again on that front. The Crazy Horse troupe came into Clark Quay (causing, among other things, the closing down of the weekend flea market which I used to go to regularly!!), followed by the long-awaited decision to allow the construction of two casinos.

So is Singapore really remaking itself, or are all these just "weapons of mass distraction" from the lack of real changes? If you use the recent election as the indicator, then you can see that the political processes, from the selection of new parliamentary candidates and their public introductions, the comparison of their first world qualifications to the lesser credentials of the opposition party candidates, the streneous search for evidence to show that opposition candidates have poor characters, the far from subtle message that voting opposition would result in poorer estate redevelopment prospects, etc, have remained the same. When a group of young people met Lee Kuan Yew for a televised dialog session, he was asked when he planned to retire. Actually, this question has been arousing attention since the early 1980s, when he approached the then standard public service retirement age of 60.

In one of the 2005 NUS centennial celebration dinners attended by a group of international university presidents (mostly from USA), PM Lee Hsian Loong was the guest of honour; following his formal speech he engaged in a dialog session with the international guests, and was asked how he saw the fostering of entrepreneurship among Singaporeans. He gave the conventional wisdom reply "reduce the role of the government". This too is very old. Starting in the 80s, companies like DBS, SIA, Capitaland (originally two parts DBS Land and Pidemco at different times), parts of the Singapore Technology Group (later all consolidated into ST Engineering), SingTel, etc were listed on the Stock Exchange by selling shares to the pubilc, originally termed "privatization" but later more accurately described as "divestiture", since control of the companies has remained under the government holding companies. During the 90s and after, these government linked companies, with deep pockets and high technical expertise, grew very large, and overshadow the few privately owned companies under local tycoon clans. (The kind of diversely held companies one sees in USA, often dominated by large pension funds in share ownership, is little known here.)

Whatever the original intentions, a number of events occurred in the business and political spheres all pushing against reducing the span of control. The Pan Electric stock market crisis, started by the collapse of several companies headed by the Malaysian politician-businessman Tan Koon Suan with a chain of debts to a number of stock broking companies forcing the market to suspend trading for several days, initiated a process whereby the stock exchange changed from a club of local stock broking firms to a listed company under government supervision. The discovery of a Marxist network in the Catholic church community started a chain of events that led to a confrontation with members of the Law Society, in which both opposition party figures and a foreign embassy played a part (leading to the expulsion of one foreign diplomat). Even the horse racing club had to be put under the control of a Totalization Board and Island Golf Club under PUB whose reservoir land the Club uses for the courses. Privatization is risky because some people who know how to pull strings can get very rich out of it (as occured in Russia in the 90s and Taiwan more recently); loosenig political control is risky because many parties, political and other kinds, are waiting to fish in the murkier waters. Singapore Inc has to stay together so that it has some weight to throw around.

A monolithic system is bound to be a ponderous one. It absorbs new ideas mostly by having these filter upwards till they stop somewhere, or hit a receptive spot where idea turns into action; it renews itself by having younger people work their way up the hierarchy till they get stuck (Peter Principle) or hit receptive openings that happen to be there. Now and then it might even stir things up a bit by bringing some ideas from the outside by hiring consultants that attach their brandnames to the ideas, or even fill vacancies with different types of people. But the system as a whole cannot easily change itself because there are so many pieces that have to fit together in order for it to operate.

In the mean time, a World Bank/IMF meeting will come to town in September, and there is a Four Million Smiles campaign right now to get people to contribute happy faces to electronic and other displays that will greet the delegates all over the country. Good things are being done, a little at a time.

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

yuen check your english grammer and spelling.

Elia Diodati said...

anonymous really ought to apply the golden rule.

Anonymous said...

someone is nitpicking; wonder why?

Yawning Bread said...

Somehow I think this piece needs a more resounding conclusion. Did a few last paragraphs get dropped by accident?

I believe the author is trying to say that there is an in-built inertia in our system, and he/she has given quite good grounds for that, but I was hoping to see the arguments wrapped up so that what I thought it was pointing to was what the author intended it to point to.

Anonymous said...

No apparently that's it...

Anonymous said...

so is SG a conservative place? does banning Playboy reduce divorces, abortions, teen pregnancies?do things change ver fast or not?

the essay is ambiguous like SG is ambiguous

Anonymous said...

yeun when you nattempt to write an essay loke your recent blog take a few english lessons before you begin. also try and come to some conclusion.

Matilah_Singapura said...

Singapore remaking itself with great regularity is like Polishing A Turd

There is no such thing as that abstraction called "society". Only real-live human beings with their own free will exist.

And if real change were to occur, it would mean that many individuals would have to change...

...from the INSIDE.

Countries don't change. Human beings do. And when they do, they act and interact differently.

yuen said...

> take a few english lessons

someone is repeatedly nitpicking..I wonder why...

> try and come to some conclusion

a little mental effort on your own would help...

Anonymous said...

Those who tells or tries to correct others' English don't seem to have perfect English themselves themselves! If you're interested in perfect English, pls join the essay writing competition elsewhere. So, pls stop this nitpicking. Here, we are more interested to encourage constructive contributions of ideas and suggestions.

Anonymous said...

anon, again you are the perfect example of a blogger using very poor english. i suggest you go back to school.

Anonymous said...

anon 10.46pm, if you think your English is superb, then by reading this blog is a suffering to you. We don't want you to suffer, you can pls read other blogs and improve your English further. Bye elite!

Anonymous said...

sorry anon, your english is not improving. i would give blogging up as a bad job. or maybe you should communicate in the island's beloved singlish.

yuen said...

I dont think that guy has a problem with imperfect english; he probably has a problem with something else but is not able to address it

if his objective is to divert the discussion away from the content, he succeeded

geneticthinker said...

Good piece of article, yuen. keep it up. I enjoy reading your effort. keep it coming.

rotor said...

If someone wants to show his good command of English, go write a book. Why should people comment on others poor language skill? Don't criticise lest you be criticisd.

Anonymous said...

it's probably an emotional hangup of some kind; dont waste time responding to him; discuss the content of the article instead

Anonymous said...

i am sure anon is saying he would be happy to comment on yuens feature, however, I can see the problems with his english. but again his messages are succinct and very interesting. yuen i would forget the anon blogger who has a hang up with the way you write. he is probably blind because he spends too much of the day pulling his old plonker.

Anonymous said...

accreditedonlinecollegeanduniversity.info

university, college and university, online university, university of phoenix, george mason university, university of phoenix online, duke university, accredited online college and university, university of florida, university of texas, university of michigan, ohio state university, university of washington, university of maryland, phoenix university, florida state university, indiana university, university of arizona, university of houston, columbia university, howard university, boston university, university of pheonix online, university of miami, online college and university
canoninkjetcartridges.net
toner cartridge, inkjet cartridge, printer cartridge, ink cartridge, cartridge, epson ink cartridge, epson inkjet cartridge, printer ink cartridge, hp ink cartridge, epson printer cartridge, lexmark inkjet cartridge, lexmark inkjet cartridge, canon ink cartridge, hp inkjet cartridge, inkjet printer cartridge, hp toner cartridge, laser printer cartridge, cartridge world, laser toner cartridge, canon cartridge inkjet, inkjet cartridge canon, discount inkjet cartridge, cheap inkjet cartridge, compatible inkjet cartridge,inkjet cartridge refill