15 Feb 2006

Three-to-one he dies ... or not

The Star Online > Lifefocus

Sunday February 12, 2006

Three-to-one he dies ... or not


Took Leng How

Last month, the Singapore Court of Appeal upheld the murder conviction of Malaysian Took Leng How. All that stands between him and the gallows is a president’s pardon or the hope that his father’s petition in Penang will succeed in persuading the authorities to commute the death sentence to life imprisonment. Since the Court of Appeal’s decision was not unanimous, BEN NADARAJAN examines the issues of reasonable doubt and majority decisions.

JUST when it looked like vegetable packer Took Leng How will take a straight walk to the noose, a three-judge Court of Appeal threw up a surprise.

In 30 previous appeals which Singapore’s highest court heard from 1990 till now, all the guilty verdicts passed by the trial judge were upheld, and all by unanimous decisions.

But in Took’s case, Justice Kan Ting Chiu said the prosecution had failed to prove conclusively that Took, 24, had smothered eight-year-old Huang Na to death on Oct 10, 2004.

In fact, Justice Kan, who has sat on the High Court Bench for the past 15 years, felt that the worst Took was guilty of was that of voluntarily causing hurt.

That only carries a maximum punishment of a one-year jail term and a S$1,000 (about RM2,300) fine, a far cry from the mandatory death penalty which the other two judges, Chief Justice Yong Pung How and Judge of Appeal Chao Hick Tin, thought he deserved.

Since Singapore’s judicial system works on a majority decision, Justice Kan’s views had no bearing on the eventual verdict and Took, kept his place on death row.

There is still one last recourse for Took: the President’s pardon.

His lawyer, Subhas Anandan, felt Justice Kan’s judgment will go some way in persuading the President to grant clemency, which has been given only six times since independence.

The two-to-one decision has raised questions about whether the executioner’s hand should be stayed.

Reasonable doubt

Senior Counsel K.S. Rajah certainly thinks so, arguing that even one dissenting judge is enough cause to raise a “reasonable doubt” whether the accused was really guilty.

“We’re talking about a person’s life here. Surely we should be 100% absolutely certain he was the one before we take his life,” said the former judicial commissioner.

The last time the Court of Appeal was split in a capital case was 10 years ago.

Then, a Myanmarese was acquitted by the trial judge of drug trafficking. The prosecution appealed and the Appeal Court set him free with a two-to-one majority.

Dr Myint Soe, who represented the Myanmar national then, said the issue was more clear-cut as the trial judge had already acquitted his client and two other appellate judges also reached the same verdict. “The trial judge’s verdict should hold more weight as he looks at all the facts and has a chance to judge for himself the demeanour and credibility of the witnesses.”

In criminal cases, the guilt of an accused person hinges on this simply-worded, yet extremely complex, term known as “reasonable doubt”.

It means that the State has to prove that there is no doubt that the person they charged did the deed.

The Singapore system

In a 1996 appeal case of a tutor who molested his student, CJ Yong made the point that while the prosecution had to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, it cannot prove its case “beyond all doubts”.

Otherwise, any fanciful suggestion can be cooked up by defence lawyers to get their clients off the hook.

“In all cases, there will always remain a minutiae of doubt,” the CJ said. ‘The question in all cases is whether such doubts are real or reasonable, or whether they are merely fanciful.”

In Took’s case, Justice Kan noted that there were no marks or bruises on Huang Na’s nose, which raised doubts as to whether Took smothered her. The defence had raised the possibility that the girl had died from fits, which the prosecution was not able to counter convincingly enough for the judge.

So should his reservations be enough to save Took?

Several states in the United States which still have capital punishment require its 12-man jury to reach a unanimous verdict before an accused can be put to death. One dissenting juror would lead to a re-trial, with a new set of jurors.

Singapore did away with the jury system for capital cases in 1969, replacing them with two-judge hearings. Both judges must see eye to eye to convict someone of a capital offence, to reduce the risk of hanging the wrong guy.

It also reflects the gravity of capital cases, which carries the ultimate punishment the legal system can mete out.

But when the late CJ, Wee Chong Jin, stepped down and CJ Yong took over in 1990, the two-judge system was replaced with just one presiding trial judge.

This was to free up more judges to hear other cases, reducing the waiting time for a case to be heard by half.

The safety catch: the CJ proposed that the State provide them with two defence lawyers instead of one.

When the change to the Criminal Procedure Code was put to Parliament in 1992, Law Minister S. Jayakumar acknowledged that having two judges try a capital case was “more comforting” than just a single judge as they shared the responsibility and also combined their knowledge of the law.

But he said that CJ Yong’s suggestion was sound as there was an “ugly and unacceptable risk” that an innocent person may spend years in prison before his trial even begins as there was a serious backlog of unheard cases.

That was over a decade ago when it took four years for a trial to begin. Now, capital cases are usually ready to go within a year.

Another safety catch: Unlike those convicted of non-capital offences, a person sentenced to death has an automatic right to appeal to a higher court. He has to inform the court if he is waiving his right.

Mathematical solution

Briton John Martin, who killed a tourist and dismembered the corpse, and Adrian Lim, who murdered two children in a religious sacrifice, both chose not to appeal and were hanged. Since there was no Round Two, there is no question of their guilt.

National University of Singapore law lecturer Michael Hor offers a mathematical solution to the conundrum.

He gave this scenario: If the trial judge acquits and the Court of Appeal is split with two judges against acquittal and one for acquittal, that means that the verdict, if one goes by simple mathematics, is tied 2-2.

Assoc Prof Hor said: ‘In such a case, then the capital conviction should not stand as there are equal number of judges for and against the conviction.’

Which means really that Took should hang since the score is really three-to-one, if you include the trial judge.

Former lawyer Prem Singh, who wrote in to The Straits Times Forum page on this issue, felt that allowing a solo dissenting voice to prevail over the majority decision “makes a mockery of our majority rule”.

Prem, who was a lawyer for 12 years before retiring in 2001, said: “The majority rule is fair. The fact that there is a dissenting decision on a murder sentence should not cloud the real issue that guilt, or whatever the judgment may be, was determined by a majority decision.”

One suggestion is to go with the majority view but give the judges the discretion to impose life imprisonment instead of the death penalty in cases which are deemed appropriate.

Singapore’s laws do not allow that and one drawback is: Do we really want to put the burden of judging whether a man should live or die on the shoulders of a few individuals, however experienced and respected?

Singapore has never shied away from defending the death penalty, seeing it as a necessary aspect of upholding law and order.

But Took’s case has raised the question: How sure should the State be about a man’s guilt before taking his life?

If the answer is 100%, then Took deserves a re-trial, hang the time and the cost.

It is, after all, a matter of life and death. – ANN/The Sunday Times


Sign The Petition.

4 comments:

Realist67 said...

Leaving this case aside, here are my views on the death penalty:

On the day you die and go to heaven, St Peter comes to decide WHETHER OR NOT to let you in at the Pearly Gates:

He asks you, "So what will it be my son [or daughter], MERCY or JUSTICE?...

96% of Singaporeans can ask for justice, but I, for one, will ask for mercy.

Other options:

Life imprisonment without chance of release. (Hopefully he/she can repent and help someone see the error of his ways?)

Also, please consider that human error can and does occur in homicide cases. The police are under pressure. People try to frame someone else to take the blame etc. If you don't kill someone, there's always a chance that new evidence will surface to prove that he or she is innocent, in which case justice can be done.

I used to work in the Straits Times: If you haven't figured it out already, 90 per cent of what you read in it should NOT be trusted.

Anonymous said...

Interesting except of Steve Chia's Speech for Human Rights Day. Full Speech at Thinkcenter.org

Steve Chia:
Two, will there be more candidates qualified to come out and contest the PAP in the GE? I don't think so. We should be lucky if the opposition can field the same or more candidates like in the 2001 GE. The cost of campaigning is not cheap. Coupled with the high election deposit (of around S$13,000,) not many people will step forward to apply for the post. Worst still, the elections law was recently changed to make it even more difficult for the opposition candidate to be nominated.

13. Now, the candidate must get his proposal, seconder and four assentors to be physically present at the nomination centre. Most new candidates will have big difficulty establishing themselves sufficiently in the newly announced electoral boundaries - to be able to convince the residents to take leave from work, to be physically present with the candidate at the nomination centre, and to be publicly identified by the PAP grassroots, RCs and CCC leaders - for political persecution later on (especially if the opposition candidate was not successfully elected in the constituency.) It takes brave and courageous residents to stand out and be counted for such a worthy cause.

14. And I must say that this is their second biggest ploy - after the GRC -- to restrict the number of opposition candidates to contest in the elections. And this law was amended and passed because the Home Minister heard a rumor -- that some opposition candidates faked the assentors' signature. Can you believe it? The law was changed based on a rumor.

Anonymous said...

Despotic govt!!!

Anonymous said...

anti spyware gratuitachat antivirusantivirus gratuitanti spywareavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavg antivirusantivirus comcomparatif antivirusantivirus downloadantivirus en ligne gratuitantivirus firewallantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus freeantivirus gratisantivirus gratuiantivirus gratuisantivirusavast antivirus gratuitantivirus ligne gratuitantivirus kasperskyantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus macantivirus mcafeepanda antivirusantivirus onlineantivirus personal editionantivirus pour scannerantivirus protectionantivirus reviewantivirus wanadooantivirus a telechargerantivirus en ligneantivirus gratuit a telechargerantivirus gratuitantivirus gratuitementanti virus softwareavastantivirus nortonantivirus softwareavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavgavg antivirusbitdefendercomparatif antivirusfirewallantivirus freeantivirus kasperskylogiciel antivirus gratuitlogiciel antiviruslogiciels antivirus gratuitlogiciels antivirusmc afeenorton 2005norton 2006meilleur antivirusnorton antivirus 2005norton antivirus 2006norton antivirusnorton ghostnorton internet securitynortonpanda antiviruspanda softwarepersonal firewallantivirus protectionremove spywaresecurity softwarespybot search and destroyspyware removalspywaresymantec antivirusspyware removertelechargement anti virus gratuittelechargement anti virustelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargement antivirustelechargement antivirustelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargements anti virus gratuittelechargements anti virustelechargements antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirustelecharger avasttelecharger norton antivirustelecharger anti virus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirusachat mp3albumsalbumbaladeur cd mp3baladeur mp3 fmbaladeur mp3cd musiquechanson a telecharger gratuitementchanson a telechargertelecharger chansonclip musiqueclip videoconvertir mp3convertisseur mp3telecharger antivirus gratuitementtelecharger avasttelecharger gratuitement anti virustest antivirusdivx dvddivx gratuitconvertisseur wma mp3mp3 downloaddvd divxdvd filmdvd musiquedvd pas cherdvd rdvd rwdvd shrinkdvd viergedvdecouter musiqueencodeur mp3telecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilmfilm a telecharger gratuitementfilm cinemafilm divx a telechargerfilm divxfilm dvdfilm gratuitfilm gratuit a telechargerfilm pirate telechargement gratuitfilm telechargementtelecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilms a telechargerfilms dvdfilms gratuitfilms a telechargerfilmsfrance musiquefree mp3jaquette filmlecteur divxjaquette dvdlecteur dvd portablelecteur dvdlogiciel mp3lecteur mp3logiciel musiquelogiciels mp3logiciels musiquemontage videomp3 arabebaladeur mp3mp3 creativemp3 downloadmp3 gratuit musiquemusic mp3mp3player mp3mp3 pas chermp3 gratuit telechargermp3 gratuittelecharger mp3mp3 musiquemp3 telecharger gratuitmp3 telechargermusic a telechargermusic a telechargermusic mp3music videoparole de musiquemusique telecharger gratuitementmusique de pubmusique alsacemusique arabemusiquemusique telechargemusique a telecharger gratuitmusique a telecharger gratuitementmusique a telecharger gratuitemusique a telechargermusique classiquemusique de filmmusique downloadmusique de filmmusique francaisemusique gratuite a telechargermusique gratuitemusique marocainemusique mp3 a telechargermusique mp3musique a telechargeparole et musiquepartition musiqueplayer mp3telecharge filmsony mp3telechargement cdtelechargement chansontelechargement musique gratuitementtelechargement divx gratuittelecharger divxtelecharger divxtelechargement film gratuittelechargement filmtelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit chansontelechargement film gratuittelechargement gratuit de musictelechargement divx gratuittelechargement gratuit emuletelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit mp3telechargement gratuit de filmtelechargement musique gratuittelechargement musique mp3telechargement musique gratuitetelechargement musiquetelechargements antivirustelechargements cdtelechargements chansontelechargements de musique gratuitementtelechargements divx gratuittelechargements divxtelechargements film divxtelechargements film gratuittelechargements film pornotelechargements filmtelechargements film xtelechargements gratuit de chansontelechargements film gratuittelechargements gratuit de musictelechargements divx gratuittelechargements gratuit mp3telechargements gratuit de musique mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements video gratuittelechargements mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements musiquetelechargements gratuit musiquetelechargements musique mp3telechargements video gratuittelechargements video xtelechargements videotelechargements winziptelecharger videotelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger des film gratuitementtelechargement film gratuittelechargement filmtelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3telecharger musique gratuitemusique telecharger gratuitementtelecharger musiquetelecharger album musiquetelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger chansonstelecharger des chanson gratuitementtelecharger clip videotelecharger des film gratuitementtelecharger divx gratuittelecharger divx gratuitementtelecharger divxtelecharger dvd gratuittelecharger dvdtelecharger film divxtelecharger film gratuittelecharger film gratuitementtelecharger filmtelecharger films gratuittelecharger films gratuitementtelecharger filmstelecharger gratuitement des chansontelecharger gratuitement musique mp3telecharger musique gratuitetelecharger gratuit filmtelecharger logiciel mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger logiciel musiquetelecharger mp3 gratuitementtelecharger mp3telecharger music gratuitementtelecharger music mp3telecharger musique filmtelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger musique gratuitementtelecharger musique mp3 gratuittelecharger musique mp3 gratuitementtelecharger musique sur mp3telecharger musiquetelecharger raptelecharger videovideoastuce msn messengeradresse msnastuce msnavatar msnclean messengere messengertelecharger videotelecharger videotelecharger videovideo clipvideo clipsvideo gratuitvideo gratuitevideo internettelecharger videovideos gratuitvideos gratuitesvideosemoticone a telecharger gratuitemoticone msn messengeremoticone a telechargeremoticone msnhotmail messengeri love messengerinstaller msn messengerinstant messengerwindows live messengerlogiciel msnlogiciels msnlogitech quickcam messengermsn messenger 7.0msn messenger 7msn messenger 8messenger 7.5messenger 7.5messengermessenger astucemsn messenger 8.0messenger betamessenger funwindows live messengermessenger msn mkt frmessenger msnyahoo messengermessenger plusmns messengermsm messengermsn 5msn 7.0 telechargermsn 7.5 telechargermsn 7.5msn 7msn 8msnmsn messenger 6msn 7.0msn messenger 7,5msn messenger 8msn messenger betamsn messenger gratuitmsn messenger macmsn web messengertelecharger msnmsn 7.5 telechargermsn 8.0msn astucemsn frmsn gratuitmsn hotmailmsn jeumsn messengermsn messenger7.5msn messenger 6.2msn plusmsn messenger 7.0msn messenger 7.5msn messenger 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7msn messenger 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7.5msn messenger 8.0msn messenger plusmsn messenger telechargermsn messenger version 7.5msn messenger version 7.5msn plus telechargermsn telechargermsn truc astucemsn truc et astucemsn webnet messengermsn web messengerlogitech quickcam messengerskin msnsmiley gratuit telechargersmiley msntelechargement gratuit msntelechargement msn 7.5telechargement msn plustelecharger msntelechargements gratuit msntelechargements msn 7.5telechargements msn plustelechargements msn 7.5telecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn gratuittelecharger msn gratuitementtelecharger msntelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.0telecharger msn plustelecharger yahoo messengertelecharger emoticone gratuittelecharger emoticone gratuitementtelecharger emoticonetelecharger emoticone msntelecharger gratuitement des emoticonetelecharger gratuitement msn 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn 7.5telecharger gratuitement msn messenger 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn messengertelecharger gratuitement msn plustelecharger gratuitement msntelecharger messenger 7.0telecharger messenger 7telecharger messengertelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger gratuittelecharger msn messenger gratuitementtelecharger msn messenger7.0telecharger msn messenger plustelecharger msn plus gratuitementtelecharger msn plustelecharger msn version 7.5msn web messengermsn web messengerweb messengerwindows live messengerwindows messengeryahoo messenger 6.0yahoo messenger 6yahoo messengertelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger gratuitementtelecharger msn messenger gratuittelecharger msn messenger7.0telecharger msn messenger plustelecharger msn plus gratuitementtelecharger msn plusmsn web messengertelecharger msn version 7.5web messengermsn web messengerwindows messengerwindows live messengeryahoo messenger 6.0yahoo messenger 6yahoo messengerachat antivirusanti spywaread awareanti spyware gratuitantivirus a telechargerantivirusantivirus gratuitbitdefenderblague blondeblague humourclone cdedonkeyemule franceemule telechargeremulefirewallhoroscope chinoisjeux a telechargerkazaa lite telechargernerokazaa litekazaa telechargerkazaalogiciel a telechargermessenger 7.5logiciel antivirusmessenger msnmp3 gratuitmp3 telechargermsn 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7.5msn telechargermusique a telechargermusique mp3nero 6telecharger anti virus gratuittelecharger acrobattelecharger antivirus gratuitementtelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirustelecharger avasttelecharger chansontelecharger clone cdtelecharger codec divxtelecharger divx gratuittelecharger divx gratuitementtelecharger divx playertelecharger divxtelecharger dvdtelecharger emoticone gratuittelecharger emoticonetelecharger emule gratuittelecharger emuletelecharger e mule gratuitementtelecharger e mule gratuittelecharger emule gratuitementtelecharger filmtelecharger frtelecharger gratuitement anti virustelecharger jeu flashtelecharger jeutelecharger kazaa en francaistelecharger kazaa gratuittelecharger kazaa gratuitementtelecharger kazaa litetelecharger les sims 2telecharger logiciel divxtelecharger logiciel gratuittelecharger messenger 7.5telecharger messengertelecharger mp3achat antivirusanti spywareanti spyware gratuitantivirus gratuitavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavg antivirusantivirus comcomparatif antivirusantivirus downloadantivirus en ligne gratuitantivirus firewallantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus freeantivirus gratisantivirus gratuiantivirus gratuisantivirusantivirus ligne gratuitavast antivirus gratuitantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus kasperskyantivirus macantivirus onlineantivirus mcafeepanda antivirusantivirus personal editionantivirus pour scannerantivirus protectionantivirus reviewantivirus wanadooantivirus a telechargerantivirus en ligneantivirus gratuit a telechargerantivirus gratuitantivirus gratuitementhttp://sudan34.ibelgique.comanti virus softwareavastantivirus nortonantivirus softwareavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavg antivirusavgbitdefendercomparatif antivirusfirewallantivirus freeantivirus kasperskylogiciel antivirus gratuitlogiciel antiviruslogiciels antivirus gratuitlogiciels antivirusmc afeemeilleur antivirusnorton 2005norton 2006norton antivirus 2005norton antivirus 2006norton antivirusnorton ghostnorton internet securitynortonpanda antiviruspanda softwarepersonal firewallantivirus protectionremove spywaresecurity softwarespybot search and destroyspyware removalspywaresymantec antivirusspyware removertelechargement anti virustelechargement anti virus gratuittelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargement antivirustelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargement antivirustelechargements anti virus gratuittelechargements anti virustelechargements antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirustelecharger avasttelecharger norton antivirustelecharger anti virus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirusachat mp3albumsalbumbaladeur cd mp3baladeur mp3 fmbaladeur mp3cd musiquechanson a telecharger gratuitementchanson a telechargertelecharger chansonclip musiqueclip videoconvertir mp3convertisseur mp3telecharger antivirus gratuitementtelecharger avasttelecharger gratuitement anti virustest antivirusconvertisseur wma mp3divx dvddivx gratuitmp3 downloaddvd divxdvd filmdvd musiquedvd pas cherdvd rdvd rwdvd shrinkdvd viergedvdecouter musiqueencodeur mp3telecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilmfilm a telecharger gratuitementfilm cinemafilm divx a telechargerfilm divxfilm dvdfilm gratuitfilm gratuit a telechargerfilm pirate telechargement gratuitfilm telechargementtelecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilms a telechargerfilms dvdfilms gratuitfilms a telechargerfilmsfrance musiquefree mp3jaquette filmlecteur divxjaquette dvdlecteur dvd portablelecteur dvdlecteur mp3logiciel mp3logiciel musiquelogiciels mp3logiciels musiquemontage videomp3 arabebaladeur mp3mp3 creativemp3 downloadmp3 gratuit musiquemusic mp3mp3mp3 pas chertelecharger mp3player mp3mp3 gratuit telechargermp3 gratuitmp3 musiquemp3 telechargermp3 telecharger gratuitmusic a telechargermusic a telechargermusic mp3music videoparole de musiquemusique telecharger gratuitementmusique de pubmusique alsacemusique arabemusiquemusique telechargemusique a telecharger gratuitmusique a telecharger gratuitementmusique a telecharger gratuitemusique a telechargermusique de filmmusique classiquemusique downloadmusique de filmmusique francaisemusique gratuite a telechargermusique gratuitemusique marocainemusique mp3 a telechargermusique mp3musique a telechargeparole et musiquepartition musiqueplayer mp3telecharge filmsony mp3telechargement cdtelechargement chansontelechargement divx gratuittelechargement musique gratuitementtelecharger divxtelecharger divxtelechargement film gratuittelechargement filmtelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit chansontelechargement film gratuittelechargement gratuit de musictelechargement divx gratuittelechargement gratuit emuletelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit mp3telechargement gratuit de filmtelechargement musique gratuittelechargement musique gratuitetelechargement musique mp3telechargement musiquetelechargements antivirustelechargements cdtelechargements chansontelechargements de musique gratuitementtelechargements divx gratuittelechargements divxtelechargements film divxtelechargements film gratuittelechargements film pornotelechargements filmtelechargements gratuit de chansontelechargements film xtelechargements film gratuittelechargements gratuit de musictelechargements divx gratuittelechargements gratuit mp3telechargements gratuit de musique mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements video gratuittelechargements mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements musiquetelechargements gratuit musiquetelechargements musique mp3telechargements video gratuittelechargements video xtelechargements videotelechargements winziptelecharger videotelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger des film gratuitementtelechargement filmtelechargement film gratuittelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3telecharger musique gratuitemusique telecharger gratuitementtelecharger musiquetelecharger album musiquetelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger chansonstelecharger des chanson gratuitementtelecharger clip videotelecharger des film gratuitementtelecharger divx gratuittelecharger divx gratuitementtelecharger divxtelecharger dvd gratuittelecharger dvdtelecharger film divxtelecharger film gratuittelecharger film gratuitementtelecharger filmtelecharger films gratuittelecharger films gratuitementtelecharger filmstelecharger gratuitement des chansontelecharger gratuitement musique mp3telecharger musique gratuitetelecharger gratuit filmtelecharger logiciel mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger logiciel musiquetelecharger mp3 gratuitementtelecharger mp3telecharger music gratuitementtelecharger music mp3telecharger musique filmtelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger musique gratuitementtelecharger musique mp3 gratuittelecharger musique mp3 gratuitementtelecharger musique sur mp3telecharger musiquetelecharger raptelecharger videovideoastuce msn messengeradresse msnastuce msnavatar msnclean messengere messengertelecharger videotelecharger videotelecharger videovideo clipvideo clipsvideo gratuitvideo gratuitevideo internettelecharger videovideos gratuitvideos gratuitesvideosemoticone msn messengeremoticone a telecharger gratuitemoticone a telechargeremoticone msnhotmail messengeri love messengerinstaller msn messengerinstant messengerwindows live messengerlogiciel msnlogiciels msnlogitech quickcam messengermsn messenger 7.0msn messenger 7msn messenger 8messenger 7.5messenger 7.5messengermsn messenger 8.0msn 5messenger astucemessenger betamessenger funwindows live messengermessenger msn mkt fryahoo messengermessenger msnmessenger plusmns messengermsm messengermsn 7.0 telechargermsn 7.5 telechargermsn 7.5msn 7msn 8msnmsn messenger 6msn 7.0msn messenger 7,5msn messenger 8msn messenger betamsn messenger gratuitmsn messenger macmsn web messengertelecharger msnmsn 7.5 telechargermsn 8.0msn astucemsn frmsn gratuitmsn hotmailmsn jeumsn messengermsn messenger7.5msn messenger 6msn messenger 7,5msn messenger betamsn messenger 8msn messenger gratuitmsn messenger macmsn web messengertelecharger msnmsn 7.5 telechargermsn 7.0msn astucemsn 8.0msn gratuitmsn frmsn hotmailmsn jeumsn messengermsn messenger7.5net messengerskin msnmsn web messengerlogitech quickcam messengersmiley gratuit telechargersmiley msntelechargement msn 7.5telechargement gratuit msntelechargement msn plustelecharger msntelechargements gratuit msntelechargements msn 7.5telechargements msn plustelechargements msn 7.5telecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn gratuittelecharger msn gratuitementtelecharger msntelecharger msn messenger 7.0telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn plustelecharger yahoo messengertelecharger emoticone gratuittelecharger emoticone gratuitementtelecharger emoticonetelecharger emoticone msntelecharger gratuitement des emoticonetelecharger gratuitement msn 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn 7.5telecharger gratuitement msn messenger 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn messengertelecharger gratuitement msn plustelecharger gratuitement msntelecharger messenger 7.0telecharger messenger 7telecharger messengertelecharger messenger 7.5telecharger messenger 7.5telecharger msn 7 gratuitementtelecharger messenger plustelecharger msn 7.0 gratuitementtelecharger msn 7.0telecharger msn 7.5 francaistelecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn 7.5 francaistelecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn 8.0telecharger msn 8.0telecharger msn betatelecharger msn gratuittelecharger msn gratuitementtelecharger msn mesengertelecharger msn messagertelecharger msntelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger gratuittelecharger msn messenger gratuitementtelecharger msn messenger plustelecharger msn messenger7.0telecharger msn plus gratuitementtelecharger msn plustelecharger msn version 7.5msn web messengermsn web messengerweb messengerwindows live messengerwindows messengeryahoo messenger 6.0yahoo messenger 6yahoo messengerachat antivirusanti spywaread awareanti spyware gratuitantivirus a telechargerantivirusantivirus gratuitbitdefenderblague blondeblague humourclone cdedonkeyemule franceemule telechargeremulefirewallhoroscope chinoisjeux a telechargerachat antivirusanti spywareanti spyware gratuitantivirus gratuitavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusantivirus comavg antiviruscomparatif antivirusantivirus downloadantivirus en ligne gratuitantivirus firewallantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus freeantivirus gratisantivirus gratuiantivirus gratuisantivirusfilm a telecharger gratuitementfilm cinemafilm divxfilm divx a telechargerfilm dvdfilm gratuitfilm gratuit a telechargerfilm pirate telechargement gratuitfilm telechargementtelecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilms a telechargerfilms dvdfilms gratuitfilms a telechargerfilmsfrance musiquefree mp3jaquette filmlecteur divxjaquette dvdlecteur dvd portablelecteur dvdlecteur mp3logiciel mp3logiciel musiquelogiciels mp3logiciels musiquemontage videomp3 arabebaladeur mp3mp3 creativemp3 downloadmp3 gratuit musiquemusic mp3mp3telechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit de filmtelechargement gratuit mp3telechargement musique gratuittelechargement musique gratuitetelechargement musique mp3telechargement musiquetelechargements antivirustelechargements cdtelechargements chansontelechargements de musique gratuitementtelechargements divx gratuittelechargements divxtelechargements film divxtelechargements film gratuittelechargements film pornotelechargements film