11 Feb 2006

Singapore Judiciary Unfair And Not Independent

Received via email today..

Statement of Chee Soon Juan submitted to the High Court, Singapore at the Bankruptcy Petition Hearing on 10 February 2006

Dr Chee Soon Juan, secretary-general of the Singapore Democratic Party, was sued in 2002 by former Singapore prime ministers Mr Lee Kuan Yew and Mr Goh Chok Tong for defamation. The courts awarded the case to the plaintiffs and ordered Dr Chee to pay $500,000 in damages. Messrs Lee and Goh then took legal action to declare Dr Chee bankrupt. In response Dr Chee submitted this statement at the bankruptcy hearing.

After much observation and having personally gone through the judicial process, I cannot but come to the conclusion that my case has not received the justice that it is entitled to; it has been crippled right from the beginning.

First, I was denied the services of QCs when the case commenced in 2002 because according to judge Tay Yong Kwang, the matter was not “complex enough”. This is in spite of the fact that I had made known the problem that few Singaporean lawyers would act for me because this involved politics. In this regard, it is instructive to note an AP report said criminal lawyer, Mr Subhas Anandan, was happy to represent “thieves and even terror suspects – but no dissidents, please.”

The fact that the plaintiffs, Mr Lee Kuan Yew and Mr Goh Chok Tong, had engaged Senior Counsel, Mr Davinder Singh, who is seasoned in handling PAP defamation lawsuits and the fact that I had no lawyer to argue my case for me seemed to not bother the courts at all. The US-based Lawyers Committee for Human Rights commented:

Neither at the hearing, on February 7 [2003], nor in the course of his judgment, did Justice Rubin display the least concern that Dr. Chee was unrepresented. The Lawyers Committee considers that this apparent lack of concern, coupled with the considerable latitude extended to Mr. Singh in his submissions to the Court, resulted in manifest unfairness in the course of the hearing and, specifically, the denial to Dr. Chee of a fair hearing that met the international norms to which we have referred.

Second, the case was awarded to the plaintiffs through Summary Judgment, which meant that I could not call witnesses and defend myself in open court. Again, the Lawyers Committee wrote:

The Lawyers Committee considers that there appear to be triable issues in this matter, such as whether or not the words spoken by Dr. Chee were defamatory and whether there was pressure brought to bear on Dr. Chee that should render his apology and admission void for duress.

In summary, not only did I not have legal representation but I also did not get a trial. It is well-known that Singapore has detention without trial. Now it seems that we also have defamation without trial.

To be sure my case is only the latest in several that have taken place through the years. Mr J B Jeyaretnam, one who has suffered the most under this legal tyranny, has had to endure much injustice. One case which he had appealed with Mr Wong Hong Toy to the Privy Council of London in 1988 will perhaps go down in judicial infamy. The Law Lords then had concluded that both the defendants had “suffered a grievous injustice” at the hands of the Singapore Judiciary and Law Society.

Another instance was the removal of former judge Mr Michael Khoo from the bench after he had passed a lenient sentence on Mr Jeyaretnam.

Through the years Mr Jeyaretnam has been hounded and was finally made bankrupt in 2001 which made him ineligible for the 2001 elections. He looks set to also be disqualified for this coming elections.

Then there was the case of Mr Tang Liang Hong who likewise was sued for defamation and made bankrupt in 1997. If ever there was any doubt as to the partiality of Singapore’s courts, this case and all its attendant proceedings removed it. It involved a police report that Mr Tang had made during the 1997 general elections about PAP leaders. Mr Lee Kuan Yew then got hold of the report, distributed it to the media, and then proceeded to sue Mr Tang for defamation.

The above have been but a small sample of instances showing the lack of independence and fairness of our judicial system. This has prompted international organizations to comment:

“Civil defamation suits are being misused by the Executive to intimidate and deter those Singaporeans holding dissenting views.” – Amnesty International

“[Defamation lawsuits have] done little to overcome the courts’ reputation as improperly compliant to the interests of the country’s ruling People’s Action Party.” – International Commission of Jurists

“What emerges…is a government that has been willing to decimate the rule of law for the benefit of its political interests. Lawyers have been cowed to passivity, judges are kept on a short leash, and the law has been manipulated so that gaping holes exist in the system of restraints on government action toward the individual. Singapore is not a country in which individual rights have significant meaning.” – New York City Bar Association

Our own former solicitor-general, Mr. Francis Seow said, “the judiciary…contort themselves into obscene positions to favour…the government.”

The US embassy in Singapore expressed concern over “the ruling party’s use of the court system to intimidate political opponents.”

Stuart Littlemore, QC, reporting for the International Commission of Jurists wrote: “The Singapore leadership has a long-standing record of using the high court as a mechanism for silencing its opponents – by suing them for statements that, in any comparable jurisdiction, would be seen as part of a robust political debate inseparable from democratic freedoms, and by being awarded such unconscionably high damages and costs as to bankrupt the defendants, forcing them out of parliament.”

More recently, Chief Justice Yong Pung How sued his former remisier, Mr Boon Suan Ban, for defamation when Mr Boon allegedly harassed Mr Yong over some financial matters. Mr Boon was subsequently arrested and remanded at the Institute for Mental Health at the “pleasure of the President.” The papers pertaining to the case were then sealed.

In 2005, High Court Judge Mr V K Rajah ruled that a silent protest staged by four activists calling for transparency and accountability from the Singapore Government was “incendiary” and that such protests would “improperly undermine both a hard-won national dignity and a reputable international identity.” This is in spite of the fact that the Singapore Constitution clear states that only five or more persons gathered in a public area constituted an illegal assembly.

The question of the independence of Singapore’s judiciary is also the subject of a dispute between two commercial companies that is taking place presently in Ontario, Canada. The arguments of one party can be found on: http://uy.http3.net/Corrupted_Singapore_Regime_Judiciary.pdf

Through the decades opposition politicians have been, and continue to be, hounded, persecuted, and prosecuted by the PAP through the courts. All this time no one in Singapore has dared to say anything. There comes a time, however, when one must look deep into oneself and ask how much more of the persecution one has to suffer in silence. Today I have made the decision not to remain silent any more and tell you what you don’t want to hear: That the judiciary in Singapore is, sadly, not independent especially when it comes to dealing with opposition politicians.

I wish I didn’t have to do this. I wish I could say that my country’s judicial system is independent and fair. But I can’t because that would be a lie. It would be a much easier decision for me, and more importantly for my family, to walk away from this bankruptcy hearing and accept the punishment that the court has meted out. But my conscience dictates otherwise and I must take the path that in all likelihood will lead to dire consequences.

However, making this statement is a decision that I have chosen and, having made it, to accept the consequences that it brings. I hope to make this statement a start to a campaign to pry the country’s judiciary from the clutches of the PAP Government.

I may or may not succeed in my endeavour, but I would rather live my life having spoken and fought for the truth than to share it with cowardice and deceit. In my little way, I would have stood up for Singapore, my home too.



Chee Soon Juan

10 February 2006

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

The end of democracy. When will fellow Singaporeans wake up to the undemocratic system we live in? How can decent human beings be jailed so easily?

Freedom of Speech! Freedom of Assembly! Singaporeans want democracy! Vote Opposition!

Anonymous said...

for anyone to win this thing is to do something against the law. it's virtually impossible for any other party to win this damn election, why is it even held.

rench00 said...

are you sure Singaporeans want democracy? are you sure Singaporeans want the right for other Singaporeans to hold protests in the streets?

i don't think so. i think most Singaporeans want to see the GDP expand, see more goodies being dished out, see taxes drop, see greater job stability, more jobs, higher pay. and if that comes at the expense of freedom of speech and assembly, then i think Singaporeans would gladly give up freedom of speech and assembly.

Singaporeans, by and large, still care more about the bread and butter issue. to think that they are not is being... misguided.

so if the opposition wants to compete, they have to convince the voters that with them in Parliament, GDP will rise higher, there will be more jobs, jobs would be more secure, pay will be higher than if they were not voted into Parliament.

and i have said it once, i will say it again. i hope that people like Sylvia Lim gets voted in. there are a few people from PAP that i would like to see people like Sylvia Lim unseat.

Anonymous said...

elections are to give the government a "mark"; each PM wants to get a high mark, or he would lose face

Anonymous said...

be like the Thais and go out and tell them "OUT!"

rench00 said...

tell them to get out... great idea!

then what? will there be anyone who can step up and do as good a job?

i think asking the whole PAP to get out is the dumbest idea i've heard.

but... i do agree, as in my comment on other post, that there should be less institutional obstacles that puts the opposition at an unfair disadvantage.

Anonymous said...

So, even if PAP were to win the election again, to me, it is nothing GLORIOUS because they always have the upper hand.

All the old-timers are offering themselves for re-election again? What kind of notion is this? Analyse for yourselves........

sglaksa said...

So anonymous thinks that people other than the PAP can do a better job? Can Dr Chee lead Singapore well? Is he Prime Minister material? In short, there isn't enough talent in Singapore and since the PAP is larger(due to history), it gets the lion share of the talent from which it draws ministers from.

Anonymous said...

I believe nobody is indispensable in this world, including PAP.

It is just that PAP has been in control and they certainly have all the avenues, the means and the finances to recruit members.

Since history, the govt has the upper hand and is constantly posing institutional obstacles to any opposition parties. I believe you can see for yourself how many opposition parties can withstand being charged and being sued till bankrupt. Before one stand up, the govt will quickly push you into the river first.

As such, how much can the opposition parties truly be able to prove themselves and be able to recruit members and staff just like PAP? One not only needs talent but finances, time, etc. Whereas majority of PAP ministers and members are on full-time basis with good pay. And whatever activities they wish to carry out are all using the public fund.

At the same time, the citizens are also being suppressed. It is not that there isn't enough talent but people are very much afraid of repercussions, so they rather choose to be passive citizens.

skl said...

Sglaksa, good questions. I don't know until he is given a chance. One thing for sure, the PAP has no confidence in themselves, otherwise they will have adopted a more open society. They still need to hide behind a myriads of anti-social laws to keep their positions.
You can answer these questions.
How good are they?
Good money making machines?
Good policemen?
Good eavesdroppers?
Good hangmen?
Good robot operators?

Jonasito said...

anti spyware gratuitavast antivirusantivirus en ligneantivirus gratuitantivirus gratuitementantivirus pour scannerantivirus softwareantivirusavast antivirusavg antivirusavgbitdefendercomparatif antivirusetrustfirewalllogiciel antivirusmcafeemeilleur antivirusnorton antivirus gratuitnorton antivirustelecharger nortonpanda antivirusspybotspywaretelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antiviruszone alarmblague blondeblague de totoblague droleblague du jourblague humourblague sur les blondeblague telephoneblague videoblaguevideo comiquediaporama humourblague humourhumour et blaguehumour gratuithumour noirhumour sexehumour sexyvideo humourhumourimage comiqueimage humourpps humourblague videovideo comiquevideo humourecran de veille gratuitecran de veillefond d ecran gratuitfond d ecran pcfond ecran sexyfond ecraniconeastuce jeu videotruc et astuceconsole jeuconsole jeuxfrancaise des jeufrancaise des jeuxtelecharger jeujeu actionjeu adultejeu arcadejeu aventurejeu concoursjeu de billardjeu de cartejeu de damejeu de motojeu de rolejeu de strategiejeu de voiturejeu diamantjeu diddljeu educatifjeu enfantjeu erotiquejeu flashjeu frjeu grattagejeu gratuit pour enfantjeu gratuitjeu javajeu en lignejeu pcjeu sexyjeu simulationjeu solitairejeu videojeutelecharger jeuxjeux actionjeux adultejeux arcadejeux aventurejeux concoursjeux de billardjeux de cartejeux de damejeux de motojeux de rolejeux de strategiejeux de voiturejeux diamantjeux diddljeux educatifjeux enfantjeux erotiquejeux flashjeux frjeux grattagejeux gratuit pour enfantjeux gratuitjeux javajeux en lignejeux pcjeux sexyjeux simulationjeux solitairejeux videojeuxpc astuceromjeu gratuit a telechargertelecharger jeujeux gratuit a telechargertelecharger jeuxtrucsclone dvdmp3 gratuitlecteur mp3musique mp3prix mp3sonnerie mp3telechargement musique mp3telecharger chansontelecharger codectelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3tous les driveradresse msnastuce msnavatarclin d oeil msnclin oeilemoticone gratuitemoticone msnemoticonemsn messengermsn 7.5msn messenger 7.5msn messengermsn plusmsn web messengermsn web messengermsnnouvelle version msntelecharger emoticonetelecharger messenger 7.5telecharger messengertelecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 8telecharger msn plustelecharger msntelecharger yahoo messengeryahoo messengerchanson arabechanson d amourchanson enfantinechanson francaisechanson paillardeparole chansonchanson pour enfantparole chansonparole chansonparole de chanson francaiseparole et chansonpartition batteriepartition clarinettepartition de chansonpartition musiquepartition flutepartition gratuitepartition guitarepartition pianopartition saxophonepartitionrire et chansontexte de chansontraduction de chansonbanque postalecarte postale virtuellecarte postaleaperitifcuisinerecette de cuisineporcpouletrecetterecette cuisinesoupe aux chouastrologie chinoiseastrologie gratuiteastrologieles chevaliers du zodiaquehoroscope 2006 gratuithoroscope 2006horoscope amoureuxhoroscope balancehoroscope belierhoroscope cancerhoroscope capricornehoroscope chinoishoroscope du jourhoroscope gemeauhoroscope gratuithoroscope lionhoroscope mensuelhoroscope poissonhoroscope sagittairehoroscope scorpionhoroscope taureauhoroscope verseauhoroscope viergehoroscopejeu de tarotsigne du zodiaquetarot marseilletarot divinatoiretarot en lignetarot gratuittarottirage tarot gratuittirage tarotzodiaquehennemodèle de tatouagepiercing languepiercing nombrilpiercingtatootatouageace mega codecacrobat readerad awarebaladeur mp3clone cdclone dvdcodec audiocodec avicodec divxcodec dvdcodec gratuitpack codeccodec videocodec xvidcodeccompressionconvertir mp3convertisseur mp3codec divxdivx gratuitdivx playerdivxdownload acceleratordriverdvd divxdvd playerdvdedonkey 2000edonkeyemule fremule franceemule gratuitemule paradiseemule plusemuleencodeur mp3enregistreur dvdgraveur dvdhp drivericqimeshjaquette dvdjavakazaa litekazaalecteur mp3logiciel a telechargerlogiciel antiviruslogiciel architecturelogiciel comptabilitelogiciel dessinlogiciel de gravuretelechargement logiciellogiciel de traductionlogiciel gratuitlogicielnero burning romnero expresspack codecripperserveur emuleshareazaskypetelechargement logiciel gratuittelechargement logicieltelechargement p2ptelecharger acrobat readertelecharger ad awaretelecharger antivirustelecharger avasttelecharger divxtelecharger e muletelecharger emule gratuittelecharger emule gratuitementtelecharger emulejeu gratuit a telechargertelecharger javatelecharger kazaa litetelecharger kazaatelecharger nero 6telecharger nero 7telecharger nerotelecharger real playertelecharger shareazatelecharger skypewinamptelecharger winziptelechargertraducteurtrillianwinmxwinrarwinzipzone alarm206 tuningaccessoire tuningaccessoire voiture tuningtuning autobmw tuningboitier tuningmoto tuningparis tuning showpiece auto tuningpiece tuningrallyscooter tuningtuning autotuningvoiture tuningblague blondeblague sur blonde blague de totoblague sur toto blague droledrole de blague blague du jourarbroscope blague jour blague humourhumour et blague blague sur les blondeblague and sur and les and blonde blague telephoneblague telephone portable blague videovideo blague blagueblague humour video comiquecomique diaporama humourhumour diaporama blague humourhumour et blague humour et blagueblague et humour humour gratuitvideo humour gratuit humour noirblague humour noir humour sexesexe humour humour sexysexy humour video humourhumour video humourhumour sexy image comiquecomique image image humourhumour image pps humourhumour pps blague videovideo blague video comiquevideo comique gratuite video humourhumour videochanson arabeparole de chanson arabe chanson d amourparole chanson amour sans amour chanson enfantineartiste divers chanson enfantine et noel chanson francaiseparole de chanson francaise chanson paillardeparole de chanson paillarde parole chansonparole de chanson francaise chanson pour enfantparole de chanson pour enfant parole chansonchanson parole chansonparole de chanson francaise parole de chanson francaisechanson francaise parole parole et chansonparole et traduction de chanson partition batteriepartition batterie gratuite partition clarinettepartition gratuite clarinette partition de chansonpartition chanson francaise partition musiquepartition musique gratuite partition flutepartition flute traversiere partition gratuitepartition piano gratuite partition guitarepartition gratuite guitare partition pianopartition piano gratuite partition saxophonepartition gratuite saxophone partitionpartition de musique rire et chansonradio rire et chanson texte de chansontexte chanson auteur traduction de chansontraduction de parole de chansonadresse msnadresse msn de fille astuce msnmsn astuce avataravatar msn clin d oeil msnclin d oeil msn gratuit clin oeilclin oeil gratuit emoticone gratuitemoticone msn gratuit emoticone msnemoticone msn gratuit emoticoneemoticone gratuit msn messengermessenger msn 7.5msn messenger 7.5 msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5 msn messengermsn web messenger msn plusmsn messenger plus msn web messengerweb msn messenger msn web messengermsn web msnmsn messenger nouvelle version msnmsn nouvelle version telecharger emoticonetelecharger emoticone gratuit telecharger messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5 telecharger messengertelecharger msn messenger 7.5 telecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5 telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5 gratuitement telecharger msn messenger 8msn 8 telecharger msn plustelecharger msn messenger plus telecharger msntelecharger msn 7.5 telecharger yahoo messengertelecharger yahoo messenger 6 yahoo messengertelecharger yahoo messenger anti spyware gratuitanti spyware avast antivirusantivirus avast antivirus en ligneantivirus en ligne gratuit antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuit antivirus gratuitementtelecharger antivirus gratuitement antivirus pour scannerscanner antivirus antivirus softwaresoftware antivirus antivirusantivirus gratuit avast antivirusantivirus avast avg antivirusantivirus avg avgavg free bitdefenderbitdefender 9 internet security comparatif antivirusantivirus comparatif etrustmy etrust firewallpix and firewall logiciel antiviruslogiciel antivirus gratuit mcafeemcafee com meilleur antivirusmeilleur antivirus gratuit norton antivirus gratuitantivirus norton gratuit norton antivirusnorton antivirus gratuit telecharger nortonnorton panda antivirusantivirus panda spybotspybot search and destroy spywarespyware removal telecharger antivirus gratuitantivirus gratuit a telecharger telecharger antivirustelecharger antivirus gratuit zone alarmzone alarm proclone dvdclone dvd 2 mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3 gratuit lecteur mp3mp3 musique mp3mp3 gratuit musique prix mp3prix baladeur mp3 sonnerie mp3mp3 sonnerie telechargement musique mp3telechargement gratuit de musique mp3 telecharger chansonchanson telecharger telecharger codectelecharger codec divx telecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger musique mp3 gratuit telecharger mp3telecharger mp3 gratuit tous les drivertous les driver .comhennetatouage au henne modele de tatouagetatouage modele piercing languepiercing bijoux langue piercing nombrilbijoux piercing nombril piercingpiercing nombril tatootribal tatoo tatouagetatouage tribal206 tuningtuning 206 accessoire tuningaccessoire voiture tuning accessoire voiture tuningaccessoire tuning pour voiture tuning autoauto tuning bmw tuningtuning bmw boitier tuningboitier pc tuning moto tuningtuning moto paris tuning showparis tuning show 2006 piece auto tuningpiece tuning auto piece tuningpiece auto tuning rallyrally live scooter tuningtuning scooter tuning autoauto tuning tuningvoiture tuning voiture tuningaccessoire voiture tuningskypetelecharger skype telechargement logiciel gratuitlogiciel de telechargement gratuit telechargement logicieltelechargement logiciel gratuit telechargement p2plogiciel telechargement p2p telecharger acrobat readertelecharger acrobat telecharger ad awaread aware telecharger antivirustelecharger antivirus gratuit telecharger avastavast telecharger telecharger divxdivx a telecharger telecharger e muletelecharger e mule gratuitement telecharger emule gratuitemule telecharger gratuit telecharger emule gratuitementtelecharger gratuitement emule telecharger emuletelecharger emule gratuitement jeu gratuit a telechargertelecharger jeu gratuit telecharger javatelecharger java script telecharger kazaa litetelecharger kazaa lite gratuitement telecharger kazaatelecharger kazaa lite telecharger nero 6telecharger nero 6 gratuit telecharger nero 7telecharger nero 7 gratuit telecharger nerotelecharger nero 6 telecharger real playertelecharger real player gratuit telecharger shareazatelecharger shareaza gratuitement telecharger skypeskype telecharger winamptelecharger winamp telecharger winziptelecharger winzip gratuit telechargertelecharger musique traducteurtraducteur anglais francais trilliantrillian pro winmxtelecharger winmx winrartelecharger winrar winzipwinzip gratuit zone alarmzone alarm proace mega codecace mega codec pack acrobat readeracrobat ad awaread aware 6.0 baladeur mp3baladeur cd mp3 clone cdcrack clone cd clone dvdclone dvd 2 codec audiotelecharger codec audio codec aviavi codec codec divxdivx codec codec dvdcodec lecteur dvd codec gratuittelecharger codec gratuit pack codeccodec pack codec videovideo codec codec xvidxvid codec codeccodec divx compressionressort de compression convertir mp3convertir mid en mp3 convertisseur mp3convertisseur wma mp3 codec divxdivx codec divx gratuitfilm divx gratuit divx playertelecharger divx player divxlecteur divx download acceleratordownload accelerator plus drivertous les driver dvd divxlecteur dvd divx dvd playerdvd player for car dvdlecteur dvd edonkey 2000telecharger edonkey 2000 edonkeyedonkey 2000 emule frtelecharger emule fr emule francefrance emuleemule gratuittelecharger emule gratuit emule paradiseemule and paradise emule plustelecharger emule plus emuleemule paradise encodeur mp3encodeur enregistreur dvdlecteur enregistreur dvd graveur dvdgraveur dvd externe hp driverdriver imprimante hp icqte cherche icq i seek you imeshimesh 5 jaquette dvdjaquette dvd gratuite javajeu java kazaa litetelecharger kazaa lite kazaakazaa lite lecteur mp3lecteur mp3 2f multim e9dia logiciel a telechargerlogiciel gratuit a telecharger logiciel antiviruslogiciel antivirus gratuit logiciel architecturelogiciel architecture 3d logiciel comptabilitelogiciel comptabilite gratuit logiciel dessinlogiciel dessin 3d logiciel de gravurelogiciel gravure dvd telechargement logicieltelechargement logiciel gratuit logiciel de traductiontraduction logiciel logiciel gratuittelechargement logiciel gratuit logiciellogiciel gratuit nero burning romnero burning nero expressnero vision express pack codeccodec pack ripperripper dvd serveur emuleliste serveur emule shareazatelecharger shareaza