16 Nov 2005

Governing the net


The debate about who governs the internet will dominate the World Summit on the Information Society meeting in Tunis this week – but the world’s web users have more important things on their mind, says Becky Hogge.

One of the biggest draws of the information technology scene is that, unlike nearly any other sector of civic life, it does not tend to attract argumentative people in the twilight of their careers debating aimlessly in closed rooms without having the first notion of what they're talking about, just because they've come to feel very lonely when not accompanied by the sound of their own voice. If technology has one central piece of lore, it is “find it, fix it”. But times they are a-changing. Take a ringside seat at WSIS round two, starting this week, and you can say you were there when the tides turned.

Instead of getting down to the real business of pondering why, if this info-juice is so wonderful and free and everything, whilst I'm timestamping my political satire .mp3 downloads on the bus, there's a whole village in east Africa sharing one mobile phone, at the UN's World Summit for the Information Society in Tunis on 16-18 November we'll be asking: who controls the net? That's right, it looks like after all this time – why, we nearly had Mr Murdoch in a sweat back there – the world wide web was something that could be controlled after all.

Also by Becky Hogge, managing editor of openDemocracy:“Patents for profit: dystopian visions of the new economy” (March 2005)“Democracy and dissent at the World Intellectual Property Organisation” (April 2005)“The great firewall of China” (May 2005)“Mozilla’s ‘magic pixie dust’” (with Hamza Khan-Cheema, September 2005)“Open source nation” (interview with Geoff Mulgan, September 2005)If you find this material valuable please consider supporting openDemocracy by sending us a donation so that we can continue our work for democratic dialogue The question being put to the floor is, should the US government cede its control of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (Icann) to the UN? To most of global civil society, the answer seems clear. Of course the internet, a global phenomenon, should be controlled by a global organisation, no matter what we might think of the UN right now. Why leave it up to the Americans? What have they done for world peace recently?

But to every point comes a counterpoint. “Will the internet become the Unternet? ” screeched Tech Central Station last month. The headline (which, however misguided, possesses a beauty to make your average sub weep) captures perfectly American fears that its homegrown, freedom-delivering invention will become bogged down in geopolitical grey goo the moment it cedes control to the UN.

The minute you scrutinse what “control” Icann currently exerts over the net, both these arguments start to look a little premature. Because the holy grail of internet governance about to be debated at WSIS is a little thing called the root zone file – the system which controls the distribution of top-level domains (like .com, .org and .net) that make up the majority of the World Wide Web. Icann maintains the root zone file by virtue of a very tight, exclusive contract with the United States department of commerce. And the reason the DoC exerts control over the root zone file is because it bought it from a geek called Jon seven years ago.

As the Internet Governance Project so rightly point out in their recent report The political oversight of ICANN (no pun intended), this knotty arrangement with Jon (now deceased, who's company, VeriSign, currently owns the largest domain-name registry business in the world) means that wresting control of the root zone file from the US commerce department would most likely involve a Congressional debate. US law and technology do not happy bedfellows make (the US Supreme Court recently outlawed the photocopier) and the prospect of a nationally-lobbied US Congress having ultimate say in the future of the root zone file is almost as haunting as that of a conglomerate of techophobe heads of state working out what to do with it.

A debate about the governance of Icann is long overdue. But what that debate is not about is freedom of speech, human rights, spam, or any other of the motley crew of concerns that have been brought to the negotiating table at WSIS. Icann may be an opaque and cumbersome organisation, but the root zone file is not the internet. George W Bush cannot delete it in a fit of neo-conservative pique.

True, religious lobbying of the DoC did result in severe delays in the assignment of a dedicated top-level domain name for pornographic material, .xxx. Further, accusations have been levelled at Icann that (rather unsurprisingly) it favours US business interests and has been slow to move on multilingual top-level domains.

Also in openDemocracy on democracy and cyberspace:Esther Dyson, “Defending ICANN – an interview” (August 2002)Solana Larsen, “The WSIS: whose freedom, whose information?” (December 2003)James Cowling, “The internet’s future in an aircraft hangar” (December 2003)Bill Thompson, “Dump the World wide Web!” (December 2004) But Icann is not watching you, nor is it scanning your correspondence for keywords like democracy. Icann is not partitioning off the bit of the web that tells you the meaning of life, or tomorrow's outcome at the horse races. Just as American liberals are wrong when they opine that ceding “control of the internet” to an international body would allow repressive regimes like Saudi Arabia and China to cripple the net overnight, so civil society is misguided when it looks to UN “control of the internet” to bridge the digital divide (and in this respect it might well like to look at the UN-sponsored International Telecommunication Union’s record on competitive internet service provision in the developing world)

Throughout its short history, Icann has tried to find ways to “control” the web beyond the assignment of top-level domains, and Icann has failed. Now it's the UN's turn to fail. “Strong feelings about protecting the internet are to be expected” wrote Kofi Annan in a tempered Washington Post editorial comment (“The U.N. isn’t a threat to the net”, 5 November 2005), his attempt at calming everyone down. But feelings, no matter how passionately felt and how eloquently debated in Tunis, will not change the internet.

Whether we rent our space in the virtual world from a US-controlled Icann or a UN-controlled Icann, in the end we, the users of the internet, are the ones in control. And the World Summit on the Information Society would better spend its time this week working out how to get the next 5 billion users onto the information superhighway, rather than wasting our time erecting the kind of top-down policy roadblocks that the “find it, fix it” web has categorically demonstrated it can easily route around.

Why the WSIS? Democracy and cyberspace Becky Hogge - openDemocracy

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

At the crux of the issue here is the clash of opinions between mainly the EU/developing nations and the US. A few years ago we wouldn't have bothered to try this at all, we're perfectly fine with the US keeping the domains. However the US has since rescinded from allowing total independence of ICANN, something which many of us find extremely disturbing.

However there are larger issues at stake here. The Internet is to put it basically, pure anarchy. To get onto the internet one must have certain defences, firewalls and antivirus not unlike guns and weapons. It's 'protect yourself on your own' on the Internet. This also has made possible freedom of speech, which we all hold dear. There is no telling what politicians might do if given the control of the Internet, especially the ineffective UN.

The way i see it, keep it the way it is, keep ICAAN as a standard for technical details like it's supposed to be! While i might not like American control, i do appreciate that they are unlike to clamp down on the freedom to be stupid, the freedom to criticize and the freedom to report.

Under centralised rule, the Internet will become like the TV, structured in such a way that true creativity will be impossible, and that technologies of today like Bittorrent which reduces distrubution costs for software (like valve's STEAM), like GOOGLE which searched the Internet(which might be censored by authorities), and even EBAY (By eager governments wanting tax $$)

Leave the internet as it is!

CFIT said...

It is time to call for ICANN transparency. What do you find most alarming about the ICANN and VeriSign settlement?

The fact that it was granted without public notice?

It will cost consumers $1.5 billion over 7 years?

It expands the VeriSign monopoly?

It grants VeriSign permanent control of the .com database?

It reduces government oversight?

Let’s hear your thoughts. http://www.cfit.info/index.html

Anonymous said...

anti spyware gratuitachat antivirusantivirus gratuitanti spywareavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavg antivirusantivirus comcomparatif antivirusantivirus downloadantivirus en ligne gratuitantivirus firewallantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus freeantivirus gratisantivirus gratuiantivirus gratuisantivirusavast antivirus gratuitantivirus ligne gratuitantivirus kasperskyantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus macantivirus mcafeepanda antivirusantivirus onlineantivirus personal editionantivirus pour scannerantivirus protectionantivirus reviewantivirus wanadooantivirus a telechargerantivirus en ligneantivirus gratuit a telechargerantivirus gratuitantivirus gratuitementanti virus softwareavastantivirus nortonantivirus softwareavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavgavg antivirusbitdefendercomparatif antivirusfirewallantivirus freeantivirus kasperskylogiciel antivirus gratuitlogiciel antiviruslogiciels antivirus gratuitlogiciels antivirusmc afeenorton 2005norton 2006meilleur antivirusnorton antivirus 2005norton antivirus 2006norton antivirusnorton ghostnorton internet securitynortonpanda antiviruspanda softwarepersonal firewallantivirus protectionremove spywaresecurity softwarespybot search and destroyspyware removalspywaresymantec antivirusspyware removertelechargement anti virus gratuittelechargement anti virustelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargement antivirustelechargement antivirustelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargements anti virus gratuittelechargements anti virustelechargements antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirustelecharger avasttelecharger norton antivirustelecharger anti virus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirusachat mp3albumsalbumbaladeur cd mp3baladeur mp3 fmbaladeur mp3cd musiquechanson a telecharger gratuitementchanson a telechargertelecharger chansonclip musiqueclip videoconvertir mp3convertisseur mp3telecharger antivirus gratuitementtelecharger avasttelecharger gratuitement anti virustest antivirusdivx dvddivx gratuitconvertisseur wma mp3mp3 downloaddvd divxdvd filmdvd musiquedvd pas cherdvd rdvd rwdvd shrinkdvd viergedvdecouter musiqueencodeur mp3telecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilmfilm a telecharger gratuitementfilm cinemafilm divx a telechargerfilm divxfilm dvdfilm gratuitfilm gratuit a telechargerfilm pirate telechargement gratuitfilm telechargementtelecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilms a telechargerfilms dvdfilms gratuitfilms a telechargerfilmsfrance musiquefree mp3jaquette filmlecteur divxjaquette dvdlecteur dvd portablelecteur dvdlogiciel mp3lecteur mp3logiciel musiquelogiciels mp3logiciels musiquemontage videomp3 arabebaladeur mp3mp3 creativemp3 downloadmp3 gratuit musiquemusic mp3mp3player mp3mp3 pas chermp3 gratuit telechargermp3 gratuittelecharger mp3mp3 musiquemp3 telecharger gratuitmp3 telechargermusic a telechargermusic a telechargermusic mp3music videoparole de musiquemusique telecharger gratuitementmusique de pubmusique alsacemusique arabemusiquemusique telechargemusique a telecharger gratuitmusique a telecharger gratuitementmusique a telecharger gratuitemusique a telechargermusique classiquemusique de filmmusique downloadmusique de filmmusique francaisemusique gratuite a telechargermusique gratuitemusique marocainemusique mp3 a telechargermusique mp3musique a telechargeparole et musiquepartition musiqueplayer mp3telecharge filmsony mp3telechargement cdtelechargement chansontelechargement musique gratuitementtelechargement divx gratuittelecharger divxtelecharger divxtelechargement film gratuittelechargement filmtelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit chansontelechargement film gratuittelechargement gratuit de musictelechargement divx gratuittelechargement gratuit emuletelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit mp3telechargement gratuit de filmtelechargement musique gratuittelechargement musique mp3telechargement musique gratuitetelechargement musiquetelechargements antivirustelechargements cdtelechargements chansontelechargements de musique gratuitementtelechargements divx gratuittelechargements divxtelechargements film divxtelechargements film gratuittelechargements film pornotelechargements filmtelechargements film xtelechargements gratuit de chansontelechargements film gratuittelechargements gratuit de musictelechargements divx gratuittelechargements gratuit mp3telechargements gratuit de musique mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements video gratuittelechargements mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements musiquetelechargements gratuit musiquetelechargements musique mp3telechargements video gratuittelechargements video xtelechargements videotelechargements winziptelecharger videotelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger des film gratuitementtelechargement film gratuittelechargement filmtelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3telecharger musique gratuitemusique telecharger gratuitementtelecharger musiquetelecharger album musiquetelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger chansonstelecharger des chanson gratuitementtelecharger clip videotelecharger des film gratuitementtelecharger divx gratuittelecharger divx gratuitementtelecharger divxtelecharger dvd gratuittelecharger dvdtelecharger film divxtelecharger film gratuittelecharger film gratuitementtelecharger filmtelecharger films gratuittelecharger films gratuitementtelecharger filmstelecharger gratuitement des chansontelecharger gratuitement musique mp3telecharger musique gratuitetelecharger gratuit filmtelecharger logiciel mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger logiciel musiquetelecharger mp3 gratuitementtelecharger mp3telecharger music gratuitementtelecharger music mp3telecharger musique filmtelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger musique gratuitementtelecharger musique mp3 gratuittelecharger musique mp3 gratuitementtelecharger musique sur mp3telecharger musiquetelecharger raptelecharger videovideoastuce msn messengeradresse msnastuce msnavatar msnclean messengere messengertelecharger videotelecharger videotelecharger videovideo clipvideo clipsvideo gratuitvideo gratuitevideo internettelecharger videovideos gratuitvideos gratuitesvideosemoticone a telecharger gratuitemoticone msn messengeremoticone a telechargeremoticone msnhotmail messengeri love messengerinstaller msn messengerinstant messengerwindows live messengerlogiciel msnlogiciels msnlogitech quickcam messengermsn messenger 7.0msn messenger 7msn messenger 8messenger 7.5messenger 7.5messengermessenger astucemsn messenger 8.0messenger betamessenger funwindows live messengermessenger msn mkt frmessenger msnyahoo messengermessenger plusmns messengermsm messengermsn 5msn 7.0 telechargermsn 7.5 telechargermsn 7.5msn 7msn 8msnmsn messenger 6msn 7.0msn messenger 7,5msn messenger 8msn messenger betamsn messenger gratuitmsn messenger macmsn web messengertelecharger msnmsn 7.5 telechargermsn 8.0msn astucemsn frmsn gratuitmsn hotmailmsn jeumsn messengermsn messenger7.5msn messenger 6.2msn plusmsn messenger 7.0msn messenger 7.5msn messenger 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7msn messenger 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7.5msn messenger 8.0msn messenger plusmsn messenger telechargermsn messenger version 7.5msn messenger version 7.5msn plus telechargermsn telechargermsn truc astucemsn truc et astucemsn webnet messengermsn web messengerlogitech quickcam messengerskin msnsmiley gratuit telechargersmiley msntelechargement gratuit msntelechargement msn 7.5telechargement msn plustelecharger msntelechargements gratuit msntelechargements msn 7.5telechargements msn plustelechargements msn 7.5telecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn gratuittelecharger msn gratuitementtelecharger msntelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.0telecharger msn plustelecharger yahoo messengertelecharger emoticone gratuittelecharger emoticone gratuitementtelecharger emoticonetelecharger emoticone msntelecharger gratuitement des emoticonetelecharger gratuitement msn 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn 7.5telecharger gratuitement msn messenger 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn messengertelecharger gratuitement msn plustelecharger gratuitement msntelecharger messenger 7.0telecharger messenger 7telecharger messengertelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger gratuittelecharger msn messenger gratuitementtelecharger msn messenger7.0telecharger msn messenger plustelecharger msn plus gratuitementtelecharger msn plustelecharger msn version 7.5msn web messengermsn web messengerweb messengerwindows live messengerwindows messengeryahoo messenger 6.0yahoo messenger 6yahoo messengertelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger gratuitementtelecharger msn messenger gratuittelecharger msn messenger7.0telecharger msn messenger plustelecharger msn plus gratuitementtelecharger msn plusmsn web messengertelecharger msn version 7.5web messengermsn web messengerwindows messengerwindows live messengeryahoo messenger 6.0yahoo messenger 6yahoo messengerachat antivirusanti spywaread awareanti spyware gratuitantivirus a telechargerantivirusantivirus gratuitbitdefenderblague blondeblague humourclone cdedonkeyemule franceemule telechargeremulefirewallhoroscope chinoisjeux a telechargerkazaa lite telechargernerokazaa litekazaa telechargerkazaalogiciel a telechargermessenger 7.5logiciel antivirusmessenger msnmp3 gratuitmp3 telechargermsn 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7.5 telechargermsn messenger 7.5msn telechargermusique a telechargermusique mp3nero 6telecharger anti virus gratuittelecharger acrobattelecharger antivirus gratuitementtelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirustelecharger avasttelecharger chansontelecharger clone cdtelecharger codec divxtelecharger divx gratuittelecharger divx gratuitementtelecharger divx playertelecharger divxtelecharger dvdtelecharger emoticone gratuittelecharger emoticonetelecharger emule gratuittelecharger emuletelecharger e mule gratuitementtelecharger e mule gratuittelecharger emule gratuitementtelecharger filmtelecharger frtelecharger gratuitement anti virustelecharger jeu flashtelecharger jeutelecharger kazaa en francaistelecharger kazaa gratuittelecharger kazaa gratuitementtelecharger kazaa litetelecharger les sims 2telecharger logiciel divxtelecharger logiciel gratuittelecharger messenger 7.5telecharger messengertelecharger mp3achat antivirusanti spywareanti spyware gratuitantivirus gratuitavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavg antivirusantivirus comcomparatif antivirusantivirus downloadantivirus en ligne gratuitantivirus firewallantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus freeantivirus gratisantivirus gratuiantivirus gratuisantivirusantivirus ligne gratuitavast antivirus gratuitantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus kasperskyantivirus macantivirus onlineantivirus mcafeepanda antivirusantivirus personal editionantivirus pour scannerantivirus protectionantivirus reviewantivirus wanadooantivirus a telechargerantivirus en ligneantivirus gratuit a telechargerantivirus gratuitantivirus gratuitementhttp://sudan34.ibelgique.comanti virus softwareavastantivirus nortonantivirus softwareavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusavg antivirusavgbitdefendercomparatif antivirusfirewallantivirus freeantivirus kasperskylogiciel antivirus gratuitlogiciel antiviruslogiciels antivirus gratuitlogiciels antivirusmc afeemeilleur antivirusnorton 2005norton 2006norton antivirus 2005norton antivirus 2006norton antivirusnorton ghostnorton internet securitynortonpanda antiviruspanda softwarepersonal firewallantivirus protectionremove spywaresecurity softwarespybot search and destroyspyware removalspywaresymantec antivirusspyware removertelechargement anti virustelechargement anti virus gratuittelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargement antivirustelechargement antivirus gratuittelechargement antivirustelechargements anti virus gratuittelechargements anti virustelechargements antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirustelecharger avasttelecharger norton antivirustelecharger anti virus gratuittelecharger antivirus gratuittelecharger antivirusachat mp3albumsalbumbaladeur cd mp3baladeur mp3 fmbaladeur mp3cd musiquechanson a telecharger gratuitementchanson a telechargertelecharger chansonclip musiqueclip videoconvertir mp3convertisseur mp3telecharger antivirus gratuitementtelecharger avasttelecharger gratuitement anti virustest antivirusconvertisseur wma mp3divx dvddivx gratuitmp3 downloaddvd divxdvd filmdvd musiquedvd pas cherdvd rdvd rwdvd shrinkdvd viergedvdecouter musiqueencodeur mp3telecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilmfilm a telecharger gratuitementfilm cinemafilm divx a telechargerfilm divxfilm dvdfilm gratuitfilm gratuit a telechargerfilm pirate telechargement gratuitfilm telechargementtelecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilms a telechargerfilms dvdfilms gratuitfilms a telechargerfilmsfrance musiquefree mp3jaquette filmlecteur divxjaquette dvdlecteur dvd portablelecteur dvdlecteur mp3logiciel mp3logiciel musiquelogiciels mp3logiciels musiquemontage videomp3 arabebaladeur mp3mp3 creativemp3 downloadmp3 gratuit musiquemusic mp3mp3mp3 pas chertelecharger mp3player mp3mp3 gratuit telechargermp3 gratuitmp3 musiquemp3 telechargermp3 telecharger gratuitmusic a telechargermusic a telechargermusic mp3music videoparole de musiquemusique telecharger gratuitementmusique de pubmusique alsacemusique arabemusiquemusique telechargemusique a telecharger gratuitmusique a telecharger gratuitementmusique a telecharger gratuitemusique a telechargermusique de filmmusique classiquemusique downloadmusique de filmmusique francaisemusique gratuite a telechargermusique gratuitemusique marocainemusique mp3 a telechargermusique mp3musique a telechargeparole et musiquepartition musiqueplayer mp3telecharge filmsony mp3telechargement cdtelechargement chansontelechargement divx gratuittelechargement musique gratuitementtelecharger divxtelecharger divxtelechargement film gratuittelechargement filmtelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit chansontelechargement film gratuittelechargement gratuit de musictelechargement divx gratuittelechargement gratuit emuletelechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit mp3telechargement gratuit de filmtelechargement musique gratuittelechargement musique gratuitetelechargement musique mp3telechargement musiquetelechargements antivirustelechargements cdtelechargements chansontelechargements de musique gratuitementtelechargements divx gratuittelechargements divxtelechargements film divxtelechargements film gratuittelechargements film pornotelechargements filmtelechargements gratuit de chansontelechargements film xtelechargements film gratuittelechargements gratuit de musictelechargements divx gratuittelechargements gratuit mp3telechargements gratuit de musique mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements video gratuittelechargements mp3telechargements musique gratuitetelechargements musiquetelechargements gratuit musiquetelechargements musique mp3telechargements video gratuittelechargements video xtelechargements videotelechargements winziptelecharger videotelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger des film gratuitementtelechargement filmtelechargement film gratuittelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3telecharger musique gratuitemusique telecharger gratuitementtelecharger musiquetelecharger album musiquetelecharger albumtelecharger cdtelecharger chansontelecharger chansonstelecharger des chanson gratuitementtelecharger clip videotelecharger des film gratuitementtelecharger divx gratuittelecharger divx gratuitementtelecharger divxtelecharger dvd gratuittelecharger dvdtelecharger film divxtelecharger film gratuittelecharger film gratuitementtelecharger filmtelecharger films gratuittelecharger films gratuitementtelecharger filmstelecharger gratuitement des chansontelecharger gratuitement musique mp3telecharger musique gratuitetelecharger gratuit filmtelecharger logiciel mp3 gratuittelecharger mp3 gratuittelecharger logiciel musiquetelecharger mp3 gratuitementtelecharger mp3telecharger music gratuitementtelecharger music mp3telecharger musique filmtelecharger musique gratuitetelecharger musique gratuitementtelecharger musique mp3 gratuittelecharger musique mp3 gratuitementtelecharger musique sur mp3telecharger musiquetelecharger raptelecharger videovideoastuce msn messengeradresse msnastuce msnavatar msnclean messengere messengertelecharger videotelecharger videotelecharger videovideo clipvideo clipsvideo gratuitvideo gratuitevideo internettelecharger videovideos gratuitvideos gratuitesvideosemoticone msn messengeremoticone a telecharger gratuitemoticone a telechargeremoticone msnhotmail messengeri love messengerinstaller msn messengerinstant messengerwindows live messengerlogiciel msnlogiciels msnlogitech quickcam messengermsn messenger 7.0msn messenger 7msn messenger 8messenger 7.5messenger 7.5messengermsn messenger 8.0msn 5messenger astucemessenger betamessenger funwindows live messengermessenger msn mkt fryahoo messengermessenger msnmessenger plusmns messengermsm messengermsn 7.0 telechargermsn 7.5 telechargermsn 7.5msn 7msn 8msnmsn messenger 6msn 7.0msn messenger 7,5msn messenger 8msn messenger betamsn messenger gratuitmsn messenger macmsn web messengertelecharger msnmsn 7.5 telechargermsn 8.0msn astucemsn frmsn gratuitmsn hotmailmsn jeumsn messengermsn messenger7.5msn messenger 6msn messenger 7,5msn messenger betamsn messenger 8msn messenger gratuitmsn messenger macmsn web messengertelecharger msnmsn 7.5 telechargermsn 7.0msn astucemsn 8.0msn gratuitmsn frmsn hotmailmsn jeumsn messengermsn messenger7.5net messengerskin msnmsn web messengerlogitech quickcam messengersmiley gratuit telechargersmiley msntelechargement msn 7.5telechargement gratuit msntelechargement msn plustelecharger msntelechargements gratuit msntelechargements msn 7.5telechargements msn plustelechargements msn 7.5telecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn gratuittelecharger msn gratuitementtelecharger msntelecharger msn messenger 7.0telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn plustelecharger yahoo messengertelecharger emoticone gratuittelecharger emoticone gratuitementtelecharger emoticonetelecharger emoticone msntelecharger gratuitement des emoticonetelecharger gratuitement msn 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn 7.5telecharger gratuitement msn messenger 7.0telecharger gratuitement msn messengertelecharger gratuitement msn plustelecharger gratuitement msntelecharger messenger 7.0telecharger messenger 7telecharger messengertelecharger messenger 7.5telecharger messenger 7.5telecharger msn 7 gratuitementtelecharger messenger plustelecharger msn 7.0 gratuitementtelecharger msn 7.0telecharger msn 7.5 francaistelecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn 7.5 francaistelecharger msn 7.5telecharger msn 8.0telecharger msn 8.0telecharger msn betatelecharger msn gratuittelecharger msn gratuitementtelecharger msn mesengertelecharger msn messagertelecharger msntelecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 7.5telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger 8.0telecharger msn messenger gratuittelecharger msn messenger gratuitementtelecharger msn messenger plustelecharger msn messenger7.0telecharger msn plus gratuitementtelecharger msn plustelecharger msn version 7.5msn web messengermsn web messengerweb messengerwindows live messengerwindows messengeryahoo messenger 6.0yahoo messenger 6yahoo messengerachat antivirusanti spywaread awareanti spyware gratuitantivirus a telechargerantivirusantivirus gratuitbitdefenderblague blondeblague humourclone cdedonkeyemule franceemule telechargeremulefirewallhoroscope chinoisjeux a telechargerachat antivirusanti spywareanti spyware gratuitantivirus gratuitavast antivirus gratuitavast antivirusantivirus comavg antiviruscomparatif antivirusantivirus downloadantivirus en ligne gratuitantivirus firewallantivirus gratuit francaisantivirus freeantivirus gratisantivirus gratuiantivirus gratuisantivirusfilm a telecharger gratuitementfilm cinemafilm divxfilm divx a telechargerfilm dvdfilm gratuitfilm gratuit a telechargerfilm pirate telechargement gratuitfilm telechargementtelecharger des film gratuitementfilm a telechargerfilms a telechargerfilms dvdfilms gratuitfilms a telechargerfilmsfrance musiquefree mp3jaquette filmlecteur divxjaquette dvdlecteur dvd portablelecteur dvdlecteur mp3logiciel mp3logiciel musiquelogiciels mp3logiciels musiquemontage videomp3 arabebaladeur mp3mp3 creativemp3 downloadmp3 gratuit musiquemusic mp3mp3telechargement films gratuittelechargement filmstelechargement gratuit de filmtelechargement gratuit mp3telechargement musique gratuittelechargement musique gratuitetelechargement musique mp3telechargement musiquetelechargements antivirustelechargements cdtelechargements chansontelechargements de musique gratuitementtelechargements divx gratuittelechargements divxtelechargements film divxtelechargements film gratuittelechargements film pornotelechargements film